Maiden Mother Matriarch with Louise Perry Trans Rights vs. Women's Rights - Robert Wintemute | Maiden Mother Matriarch Episode 147
Jun 11, 2025
Robert Wintemute, a Professor of Human Rights Law at King's College London and author, delves into the nuanced debate between trans rights and women's rights. He unpacks the slogan "trans rights are human rights" and reflects on his own change of perspective regarding the trans movement. Key topics include the housing of trans women in men's prisons, the complexities surrounding marriage laws and spousal consent, and the contentious definitions of womanhood. Wintemute advocates for dialogue amidst the evolving cultural landscape of rights.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
No Absolute Human Rights
- The phrase "trans rights are human rights" is a political slogan that ignores the reality of conflicting rights.
- Human rights must be balanced and reconciled case by case, as no rights except freedom from torture are absolute.
Shift in Trans Rights Views
- Robert Wintemute changed his view about transgender rights after confronting unreasonable demands.
- He realized that trans rights do not trump other human rights, highlighting conflicts with women's rights.
Classroom Clash on Spousal Veto
- A transgender student violently rejected Robert's explanation about the spousal veto in the Gender Recognition Act.
- This confrontation revealed to Robert that trans activists may not acknowledge the rights of others.
