Prospects for Immigration Reform amid Declining Public Support
Aug 7, 2024
auto_awesome
David Bier, an expert in immigration policy, explores the shifting landscape of public support for legal immigration and its implications. He delves into the contrasting immigration strategies of Trump versus Harris, emphasizing the missed opportunities by the current administration to highlight immigrants' economic contributions. Bier critiques the dangers of mass deportation proposals that threaten communities and advocates for recognizing the essential role immigrants play in bolstering the U.S. economy and social fabric, countering negative stereotypes.
The Biden administration is attempting to reverse restrictive immigration policies from the Trump era while maintaining a limiting stance on asylum.
Economic concerns linked to a declining working-age population highlight the crucial role of immigrants in driving growth and reducing national debt.
Deep dives
Immigration Policy Shifts Under Biden
The Biden administration has made efforts to reverse the reduction of legal immigration that occurred during the Trump era, despite criticisms regarding the pace and extent of these changes. It has repealed many restrictions imposed on legal immigration and, in some cases, expanded the system beyond its previous capacity before Trump took office. However, the administration has largely maintained a restrictive stance on asylum policies, reflecting some alignment with prior administration viewpoints. Critics argue that both Biden and Vice President Harris have failed to defend the positive contributions of immigration, missing opportunities to reshape the narrative and public perception surrounding it.
Economic and Social Benefits of Immigration
Immigrants are considered essential for bolstering the U.S. economy by filling workforce gaps and driving economic growth, especially in areas with smaller welfare states. With a declining working-age population, the economic implications of halting immigration could lead to higher inflation and reduced living standards. The Congressional Budget Office projects significant debt reduction associated with the undocumented population, highlighting the long-term financial benefits of immigration. Furthermore, historical trends show that immigration has positively influenced urban areas experiencing decline, countering crime rates and revitalizing communities through increased economic activity.
Public support for fostering robust legal immigration has taken a dramatic negative turn. What's likely under a Trump or Harris administration on immigration? David Bier comments.