Eleanor West, a housing policy researcher and former member of New Zealand's Generation Zero, discusses the nation's bold steps to combat housing crises. She highlights the transformative impact of the 2011 Christchurch earthquake, which spurred significant reforms. West also delves into the contrasts between New Zealand's urban planning and U.S. policies, detailing generational shifts in climate activism. Expect insights on the challenges of political resistance, communal interests, and how innovative zoning can enhance housing availability.
New Zealand's housing crisis prompted significant policy changes, providing valuable lessons for countries like the United States in addressing similar challenges.
The 2011 Christchurch earthquake catalyzed a rapid shift in zoning regulations, illustrating how urgent demand can reshape housing policies effectively.
Changing generational perspectives on urban development highlight the need for a balanced approach to environmentalism and housing affordability in policymaking.
Deep dives
Understanding Global Housing Crises
Housing crises are not unique to any one country, as evidenced by the challenges faced by both the United States and countries like New Zealand. The discussion reveals that global patterns, such as affordability and suburbanization, can help inform local policy debates. New Zealand's experience, with its housing crisis reportedly surpassing that of the U.S., offers valuable insights into the impacts of zoning and land use regulations on housing availability. By examining similarities in these issues, countries can better understand and develop effective strategies to combat their own housing challenges.
The Christchurch Earthquake and Upzoning
The 2011 Christchurch earthquake served as a pivotal moment in New Zealand's housing policy, resulting in significant changes to zoning regulations. In response to a heightened housing demand following the disaster, the national government relaxed zoning laws, allowing for a rapid increase in housing development. This change led to a substantial supply shock in the market, which ultimately stabilized house prices in Christchurch while prices soared elsewhere in the country. The urgency to rebuild and the immediate recognition of the housing shortage facilitated a cooperative effort between local and national officials to address these critical needs.
Auckland's Ambitious Upzoning Efforts
Auckland underwent a significant upzoning initiative in the early 2010s that aimed to address housing shortages caused by rampant suburban sprawl and rising population demands. The Auckland Unitary Plan, adopted in 2016, allowed for increased building density across much of the city, with a focus on creating a compact urban environment. Despite initial resistance from residents who feared changes to their neighborhoods, the plan led to thousands of new housing permits and substantial decreases in projected future rents. This large-scale upzoning approach stands in contrast to smaller, piecemeal reforms often seen in other regions, demonstrating a more extensive commitment to tackling housing supply issues.
National Policy Shifts and Political Dynamics
The introduction of recent housing policies in New Zealand reflects a significant shift in political dynamics, demonstrating cross-party support for upzoning. The Labour Party's 2020 National Policy Statement on Urban Development mandated that local councils raise building height limits around transit corridors, enhancing housing capacity in urban areas. In a notable turn, the National Party supported these policies, aligning with previous efforts to address the housing crisis through a mix of regulatory relaxations. However, not all policies encountered smooth sailing, as backlash against the perceived secrecy of the decision-making process illustrated the delicate balance politicians must maintain between development and local community concerns.
Cultural Attitudes Toward Development and Environmentalism
The cultural context in New Zealand surrounding property rights and urban development presents unique challenges, particularly regarding generational perspectives on environmentalism and housing. Traditional views of environmental protection often emphasized conservation and limitations on development, while newer generations are beginning to advocate for policy changes that promote urban density and sustainability. This shift illustrates a changing narrative where younger activists frame upzoning as essential to addressing climate change and housing affordability. The conversation around housing policy is evolving as younger voters increasingly recognize the benefits of thoughtful urban planning, seeking to bridge the gap between environmental and housing needs.
New Zealand was in a major housing crisis. But then the Pacific nation actually took ambitious steps to address it. The researcher Eleanor West recounts the policy wins and political pitfalls of what happened—and what lessons the United States and other countries could learn.
Share understanding this holiday season. For less than $2 a week, give a yearlong Atlantic subscription to someone special. They’ll get unlimited access to Atlantic journalism, including magazine issues, narrated articles, puzzles, and more. Give today at TheAtlantic.com/podgift.
