David Edgerton, a historian of science and technology at King's College London, dives into the contradictions of our chaotic world. He discusses how oligarchs reshape capitalism amid a global crisis and analyzes China's dual role as a challenger and contributor to social disparities. The conversation explores the turbulent relationship between war and innovation, while highlighting the struggles of the Left to articulate coherent responses. Edgerton also critiques the media landscape and the complexities of misinformation, emphasizing the need for thoughtful dialogue in these times.
The absence of effective countervailing powers against capitalism has allowed a radical elite to dominate policy-making without challenge.
China's integration into the global economy positions it as a competitor, rather than a transformative force for socio-economic justice.
Fragmented discourse and rampant disinformation complicate coherent political engagement, particularly for leftist movements striving for unity and collective action.
Deep dives
The Crisis of Countervailing Power
The current global crisis stems significantly from the absence of effective countervailing powers against capitalism. Historically, various blocs and social movements provided opposition to capitalist interests, but this opposition has weakened considerably. As a result, the balance of power has shifted, allowing for a radical elite to dominate policy-making without facing significant resistance. This lack of organized opposition has contributed to the rapid evolution of capitalism into oligarchy, with powerful interests leveraging their influence unchallenged.
China's Role in Global Power Dynamics
China is often viewed as a potential countervailing force to Western hegemony, but its influence is nuanced. While it presents an alternative geopolitical power, it does not necessarily challenge the predominant capitalist structure or address global inequalities. Instead, China's rapid industrial growth and integration into the global economy represent a formidable competitor rather than a transformative force for socio-economic justice. As it strengthens its position, it can provoke reactions from the U.S. and Europe that may lead to a re-evaluation of industrial policies, yet it does not inherently redistribute power or wealth.
The Material Politics of War
Discussions around war often romanticize its potential for innovation and progress, yet this perspective overlooks the material realities at play. War can indeed drive certain technological advancements, but it often neglects broader social benefits that might flourish in peacetime. The elite's fascination with war as a mechanism for revitalization may stem from a disconnect with those who bear the consequences of such conflicts. Ultimately, focusing solely on war as a catalyst for progress could undermine meaningful contributions to societal well-being.
The Fragmentation of Political Discourse
The contemporary political landscape is marked by a fragmentation of discourse that complicates coherent communication and collaboration. With numerous media outlets and platforms promoting individual narratives, it becomes increasingly challenging to establish common ground for collective action. This dispersion is particularly evident on the left, where disparate factions struggle to unify around shared goals and strategies. The far-right, conversely, has effectively coordinated messaging and mobilization, leaving the left at a disadvantage in terms of coherent political engagement.
The Challenge of Honest Discourse
A significant barrier to effective political action today is the erosion of honest and transparent public discourse. The deliberate flooding of information with disinformation undermines the ability to engage in constructive debate. This climate makes it difficult to discern reliable data and insights necessary for informed decision-making. Consequently, the lack of clarity regarding public policies and their ramifications leads to disillusionment among citizens and hampers the ability of leftist movements to propose compelling alternatives.
The world’s most famous face of renewable solutions spent a record-breaking amount to get Big Oil’s candidate into the White House. The ruling communist party of China is backed by Chinese billionaires. Political pundits are whipping up war fever without reason. The international rule book is merely scattered pages in the wind. And, in the midst of it, the Left is struggling to produce a coherent and collective analysis.
David Edgerton, historian and author of The Rise and Fall of the British Nation, joins me to explain how we are in a unique period of history, pointing to changing geopolitical relations, emboldened authoritarians, oligarchic capitalists and flailing climate policy as evidence. We discuss the contradictions which make this world so hard to navigate, and probe the failures of Leftist discourse to make sense of the mess. This broad conversation covers war, productivity, dematerialisation, power and information — explaining why it’s so hard to keep up with a rapidly changing world.
Planet: Critical is 100% independent and community-powered. If you value it, and have the means, become a paid subscriber today.
