My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark MFM Minisode 454
Sep 22, 2025
This week features bizarre hometown tales, from a wild Wisconsin hunting weekend gone wrong to a spooky sorority stalker. Listeners share quirky childhood stories, including a woman sent to retrieve keys by a stranger and a grandmother who faked her own death to scare off bullies. Team-building confessions add to the laughter as unhinged questions reveal secrets, leading to a partner who turns out to be the stuff of urban legends. It's a rollercoaster of humor and chills!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Wisconsin Hunting Weekend Gone Wrong
- Karen recounts a Wisconsin hunting weekend where her 13-year-old uncle drank heavily and accidentally blocked a fire truck while a neighbor's house burned.
- Despite drunken recklessness, no one was seriously hurt and the family reflects fondly on the wild story.
Sorority Stalker Caught By Authorities
- A college campus was terrorized by anonymous threatening texts and packages targeting a Sigma Kappa sorority.
- The FBI tracked the stalker to Long Island and arrested an ex-boyfriend before he could escalate further.
Child Sent Alone With A 'Courtesy Driver'
- Karen describes being sent as a seven- or eight-year-old by her mother with a store 'courtesy driver' to fetch spare keys from home.
- She survived but calls it poor parenting and warns against sending children with strangers.