

Are we 'born obsolete'? How technology makes us feel ashamed
18 snips Sep 4, 2025
In this enlightening discussion, Chris Muller, a media professor and translator of Günther Anders' work, alongside Olivia Trono, an Ideas contributor focused on the philosopher’s concepts, and Jason Dossey, a technology critique expert, delve into the haunting notion of 'Promethean shame.' They explore how technology, from AI to social dynamics, influences our self-worth and moral responsibilities. The conversation highlights Anders’ futuristic insights and their relevance to today's technological crises, urging a more ethical engagement with our advancements.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Promethean Shame Defined
- Günther Anders coined “Promethean shame” to describe feeling humiliated by the superior quality of our creations.
- He argued that better-made machines make humans feel obsolete and embarrassed by their bodies and minds.
Ken Jennings' Watson Moment
- Ken Jennings recounts losing to IBM’s Watson on Jeopardy and feeling obsolete afterward.
- He compares the feeling to a 1980s factory worker seeing a robot take over his job.
Bodies Judged Like Products
- Anders observed people hiding their hands at tech exhibitions, ashamed of bodily clumsiness next to perfected machines.
- He argued we begin to assess ourselves as products, describing bodies as 'broken' or in need of 'new organs.'