Ideas

Are we 'born obsolete'? How technology makes us feel ashamed

18 snips
Sep 4, 2025
In this enlightening discussion, Chris Muller, a media professor and translator of Günther Anders' work, alongside Olivia Trono, an Ideas contributor focused on the philosopher’s concepts, and Jason Dossey, a technology critique expert, delve into the haunting notion of 'Promethean shame.' They explore how technology, from AI to social dynamics, influences our self-worth and moral responsibilities. The conversation highlights Anders’ futuristic insights and their relevance to today's technological crises, urging a more ethical engagement with our advancements.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Promethean Shame Defined

  • Günther Anders coined “Promethean shame” to describe feeling humiliated by the superior quality of our creations.
  • He argued that better-made machines make humans feel obsolete and embarrassed by their bodies and minds.
ANECDOTE

Ken Jennings' Watson Moment

  • Ken Jennings recounts losing to IBM’s Watson on Jeopardy and feeling obsolete afterward.
  • He compares the feeling to a 1980s factory worker seeing a robot take over his job.
INSIGHT

Bodies Judged Like Products

  • Anders observed people hiding their hands at tech exhibitions, ashamed of bodily clumsiness next to perfected machines.
  • He argued we begin to assess ourselves as products, describing bodies as 'broken' or in need of 'new organs.'
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app