In this week's episode of Smart in Public, The Katies dissect Jimmy Kimmel's media controversy involving FCC threats + Disney's response strategy and Australia's Optus telecommunications crisis that left customers unable to call emergency services. This episode unpacks what happens when crisis management goes right—and catastrophically wrong.
What we covered for Jimmy
- The FCC's unprecedented response: How FCC Chairman Brendan Carr threatened ABC's broadcast licenses
- Disney's communication strategy: Why the entertainment giant's immediate capitulation to suspend Kimmel "indefinitely" revealed fundamental flaws in their crisis playbook and values as an organization
- Kimmel's comeback masterclass: How the comedian returned with emotional accountability, strategic praise for unexpected allies, to turn a cancellation attempt into 8 million YouTube views
- The censorship debate: Whether this represents a dangerous precedent for freedom of speech in comedy and media
- Corporate values vs. business interests: How Disney's regulatory vulnerabilities (ESPN/NFL deals) influenced their decision-making
What we covered for Optus
- The technical vs. reputational crisis: How operational failures in essential services create unique PR challenges
- Communication speed and transparency failures: Why Optus's response was too slow, too technical, and too disconnected from human impact
- Stakeholder prioritization mistakes: The fatal error of not immediately addressing customer safety concerns
- Regulatory complications: How government oversight changes crisis communication strategies
- The humanity deficit: Why technical explanations without empathy destroy public trust
- Rebuilding trust: The long road ahead for companies that fail during public safety emergencies
Episode Chapters & Timeline
- 05:59 - Jimmy Kimmel's controversial comments breakdown
- 08:48 - The role of comedy in political discourse analysis
- 11:32 - Escalation timeline and media response
- 14:34 - Disney's decision and corporate values examination
- 17:31 - The slippery slope of censorship debate
- 20:35 - Public reaction and media influence
- 23:37 - Jimmy Kimmel situation conclusion
- 29:19 - Viewer reactions and industry response
- 30:06 - Jimmy Kimmel's return: communications strategy analysis
- 32:17 - Optus crisis case study begins
- 36:58 - Emergency services fallout and accountability
- 43:02 - Humanity in corporate communication discussion
- 49:25 - Rebuilding trust: the path forward for Optus
Connect with us on:
Have a topic or a guest idea? Email us at hello@smartinpublicpod.com