Israel-Hamas, Year One (Robert Wright, Derek Davison, and Daniel Bessner)
Sep 19, 2024
auto_awesome
Robert Wright, a renowned commentator on global affairs, joins Middle East analyst Derek Davison and foreign policy scholar Daniel Bessner to dissect the lingering impacts of the Israel-Hamas conflict. They discuss whether a different U.S. president would have altered the situation in Gaza and the retreat of Saudi-Israel normalization efforts. The trio deep dives into the diminishing prospects for a two-state solution, while also parsing the implications of Israel's recent actions in Lebanon, painting a complex picture of regional geopolitics.
The podcast highlights how the Biden administration's approach to Israel may have contributed to exacerbating the Israel-Palestine conflict post-October 7th.
Saudi Arabia's recent reluctance to normalize ties with Israel underscores the growing importance of Palestinian statehood in regional geopolitics.
Deep dives
Escalation of Conflict and Predictions
Recent discussions highlight a significant escalation in the Israel-Palestine conflict, particularly following the events of October 7th. Predicted outcomes, such as Israel's severe retaliation and the resulting civilian toll, have materialized in ways that surprised many analysts, who did not anticipate the extent of violence. The focus shifted to how the Biden administration's stance on Israel might contribute to this trajectory, with questions raised about whether Biden's leadership style has indirectly allowed Israel to act without restraint. The situation emphasizes that predictions about geopolitical conflicts carry considerable uncertainty and that the reality on the ground frequently exceeds even the most dire forecasts.
Domestic Politics Influence U.S. Foreign Policy
The discussion reveals that American domestic politics play a critical role in shaping foreign policy, especially concerning Israel. This perspective challenges traditional views that prioritize strategic interests in foreign relations, suggesting that institutional factors and political pressures significantly influence decisions. The analysis points out that even amid grave humanitarian crises, political considerations can deter leaders from exerting leverage over Israel. The authors argue that understanding this dynamic is essential for those seeking to advocate for change in U.S. foreign policy approaches.
Saudi Arabia's Position on Normalization
Saudi Arabia's recent statements indicate a reluctance to normalize relations with Israel without significant progress on Palestinian statehood. This marks a return to the long-standing Arab League position, asserting that normalization hinges on the establishment of a Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital. The change in stance appears to be a reaction to heightened awareness and sensitivity towards Palestinian suffering in the wake of escalating violence. This evolution underscores the complex interrelation between regional politics and the U.S.'s hopes for stronger ties between its allies in the Middle East.
Implications of U.S. and Israeli Military Actions
The discussion examines the implications of recent Israeli military actions, particularly the controversial decision to sabotage devices in civilian areas, raising moral and strategic concerns. Analysts suggest that these actions reflect a disregard for civilian life that could exacerbate regional tensions and provoke further dissent. There is also speculation about the long-term viability of Israeli policies that rely heavily on military force without addressing underlying grievances. This situation illustrates the fraught dynamics of using military solutions in a context where diplomatic resolutions are becoming increasingly elusive.
Would a different US president have made a difference for Gaza? ... Saudi-Israel normalization takes a step back ... Is all hope lost for a two-state solution? ... Making sense of Israel’s pager attacks in Lebanon ... Heading to Overtime—and an AP PSA ...
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode