BibleThinker "Mary" is bad. My review of Netflix's rewrite of the virgin Mary.
42 snips
Dec 12, 2024 A critical examination of Netflix's portrayal of the Virgin Mary reveals significant narrative flaws and historical inaccuracies. The podcast discusses how modern adaptations attempt to redefine Mary as a strong female figure, yet strays from biblical texts. The theological implications of Mary's role versus Jesus in salvation are also explored, alongside ethical dilemmas in preaching influenced by personal motives. Controversies around adaptations like 'I Am the Immaculate Conception' highlight differing beliefs and underscore the importance of aligning representations with scripture.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Broad Appeal, Narrow Acceptance
- Netflix's "Mary" movie aims for broad appeal but risks offending many.
- It adapts the Proto-Evangelion of James, a historically disputed text.
Disputed Source Material
- The movie's source is the Proto-Evangelion of James, rejected by historical figures.
- Even popes advised against its use, raising concerns about the film's basis.
Genre Mismatch
- The film attempts a "biblical thriller" that is "theologically solid."
- Mike Winger finds it achieves neither, failing to reach its intended audience.