Crime Friday: Frozen Kansas City Chiefs Fans, and Fani Willis Admits Affair, with Arthur Aidala, Mark Eiglarsh, and Charlie Condon | Ep. 716
Feb 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Attorneys Arthur Aidala and Mark Eiglarsh discuss the illegal migrants beating up a police officer, the case of frozen Kansas City Chiefs fans with fentanyl in their system, and Fani Willis admitting to an affair. Charlie Condon joins to discuss why Alex Murdaugh did not get a new trial over alleged 'jury tampering'.
Parents' accountability for their child's actions in school shootings sparks debate on parental responsibility.
Skepticism arises regarding Jennifer Crumbly's claim of being unaware of her son's mental health issues.
Charges against Jennifer Crumbly for her role in the school shootings raise concerns about shifting blame away from the perpetrator.
Alec Murdoch case prompts reflection on the South Carolina legal system and the need to address vulnerabilities.
Deep dives
Jennifer Crumbly denies having mental health concerns about her son
Jennifer Crumbly, the mother of the teenage shooter who killed four people in a Michigan school, took the stand and denied having any mental health concerns about her son. She claimed that she believed they had a close relationship and that she had an open-door policy for him to come to her about anything. She stated that her son had only expressed anxiety about his future after high school. and that she never thought he needed mental health treatment. She said she trusted him and did not suspect any violent tendencies.
Opinions differ on whether Jennifer Crumbly should be charged for the shootings
There is a debate about whether Jennifer Crumbly should be charged for her role in the school shootings. Prosecutors argue that she and her husband were aware of their son's mental health issues and the troubling signs at school, yet failed to take any action to prevent the shootings. Critics argue that holding the parents responsible for the actions of their adult son sets a dangerous precedent and that they cannot be held solely responsible for his actions. The case raises questions about parental responsibility and accountability for the actions of their children.
Jennifer Crumbly's testimony is met with skepticism
Jennifer Crumbly's testimony about her relationship with her son and her lack of awareness regarding his mental health issues is met with skepticism. Many find it hard to believe that a parent could be completely unaware of their child's struggles, especially when the school had raised concerns and warnings were evident in the form of disturbing drawings and behavior. The defense argues that her testimony aligns with her position that she should not be held criminally responsible for the shootings, while skeptics question her credibility and level of involvement.
Debate over the charges against Jennifer Crumbly
The charges against Jennifer Crumbly for her alleged role in the school shootings spark a debate. Some argue that holding parents accountable for their child's actions is a step towards addressing the issue of gun violence and ensuring parents take responsibility for their children's behavior. Others are concerned that it sets a dangerous precedent and shifts blame away from the individual who committed the crime. The outcome of the case will have implications on the legal responsibility of parents in future cases involving school shootings and acts of violence.
The judge denies a new trial for Alec Murdoch
Judge Tolle denies Alec Murdoch's motion for a new trial in the murder case. The defense argued that the court clerk's interference with jurors influenced the verdict. However, Judge Tolle set a high standard for granting a new trial, requiring proof that the interference mattered and directly affected the verdict. One juror testified that the court clerk made comments that influenced her, but later clarified that other jurors pressured her. Despite this, Judge Tolle found that the evidence did not meet the standard for a new trial.
Credibility concerns over court clerk Becky Hill
Court clerk Becky Hill's credibility was called into question during the trial. While she was initially well-regarded, allegations arose of her interference and possible collaboration with her son, who also worked in the court system. Judge Tolle, in cross-examining Hill, highlighted inconsistencies and discrepancies in her testimony. This, along with Hill's own statements in her book and during the trial, diminished her overall credibility.
Strong evidence against Alec Murdoch
The trial presented a significant amount of evidence against Alec Murdoch. The mountain of evidence painted a damning picture, and even Murdoch's own testimony did not help his case. Judge Tolle, having reviewed the entire record, found the evidence overwhelming and believes it supports the guilty verdict. The jurors' testimony also indicated that their decision was solely based on the evidence presented during trial.
Reflections on the case and legal system
The Alec Murdoch case has prompted reflection on the South Carolina legal system and the need to address any vulnerabilities. The case revealed the importance of trust and the need for procedures to prevent wrongdoing. It serves as a reminder for judges, lawyers, and the legal system as a whole to be vigilant and take action when any signs of misconduct or fraud arise.
Megyn Kelly is joined by attorneys Arthur Aidala and Mark Eiglarsh, to discuss the illegal migrants beating up a police officer in New York City, whether the judge should have set bail, if they should serve time in the U.S. or be deported, three Kansas City Chiefs fans were found frozen and dead outside their friend’s house who is called “The Chemist,” the bodies were found to have fentanyl in their system, whether the friend should be put in jail not rehab, whether Fani Willis will be kicked off her RICO case against Trump and others, the Georgia judge who will have to make the decision whether to remove her, if removing Willis will torpedo the entire Trump case, Fani Willis finally admitting to the affair with her prosecutor, if Trump will have to pay E. Jean Carroll the giant judgement against him, the parents of a school shooter on trial for the first time ever, the warning signs she may have missed or ignored, the criminal standard for a parent to be responsible, Alec Baldwin now charged again for set shooting, and more. Then Charlie Condon, co-host of "The Murdaugh Murders, Money & Mystery" podcast, to discuss why Alex Murdaugh did not get a new trial over alleged "jury tampering," what jurors said when pressed by the judge, if Murdaugh might have a chance in the future with his appeal, what the future holds for Becky Hill, and more.
