In this conversation, Professor Dieter Helm, a prominent energy policy expert from New College, Oxford, delves into the profound complexities of global energy consumption and its implications for achieving net zero emissions. He discusses the historical ties between energy use and economic growth, the growing demands of developing nations, and the pressing need for technological advancements. Helm also addresses public perceptions regarding renewable energy costs and the often-overlooked role of nuclear power in the transition to sustainability.
The historical reliance on fossil fuels, particularly coal and oil, has fundamentally transformed economies and societies, necessitating a significant overhaul of our energy systems to address current climate challenges.
Despite substantial public support for renewable energy, there exists a notable hesitance to accept personal financial sacrifices, complicating the transition to a low-carbon economy for policymakers.
Deep dives
The Energy Revolution and Its Historical Context
Energy plays a crucial role in shaping economies and societies, with the historical reliance on fossil fuels, particularly coal and oil, significantly transforming human development. The Industrial Revolution, initially powered by coal, marked the beginning of dramatic increases in energy consumption, which rose from around 12,000 terawatts in 1900 to about 180,000 terawatts today. This shift enabled advancements like steam power for factories and railways, which ultimately facilitated mass production, transportation, and population growth worldwide. Understanding this history is essential for addressing current climate challenges, as the structure of our energy system relies heavily on these fossil fuels, leading to environmental issues that necessitate a fundamental energy overhaul.
Future Energy Demands and Global Trends
The future energy landscape presents immense challenges, as global energy dependence on fossil fuels remains over 80%, particularly in developing countries like India and Indonesia where rapid economic growth drives energy demand. As modernization continues, aspirations for luxuries such as air conditioning will significantly increase energy requirements, exacerbating existing issues related to climate change. Additionally, the rise of energy-intensive technologies such as data centers will further complicate the energy trajectory in the coming decades. It will be imperative to address this growing demand through sustainable solutions, particularly as developing nations seek to achieve living standards comparable to those in wealthier countries.
Public Perception of Climate Action and Energy Policy
Public opinion surveys reveal a substantial concern over climate change, with around 80% of people expressing a desire for a transition to renewable energy sources while also resisting cost increases associated with such initiatives. While there is broad public support for renewable energy, there is hesitance to accept personal financial sacrifices in exchange for environmental benefits, indicating a disconnect in expectations. Many individuals wish for the necessary changes to occur without feeling any negative impacts on their lifestyle or finances. This complexity poses significant challenges for policymakers, who must find ways to bridge the gap between public sentiment and the economic realities of transitioning to a more sustainable energy system.
The Importance of Realistic Energy Transition Strategies
The transition to a low-carbon economy must be approached with realism, acknowledging that simply switching from fossil fuels to renewable sources will not be straightforward or inexpensive. Current assumptions that renewable energy sources are significantly cheaper overlook the inherent costs associated with establishing a reliable energy infrastructure to replace fossil fuels. Moreover, the demand for energy continues to rise, necessitating strategic choices about which technologies and energy sources to invest in to maximize impact. Emphasizing comparative advantages in renewable energy technologies and recognizing the public's willingness to support initiatives that align with their values will be crucial in shaping an effective and sustainable energy future.
How much energy do we use and where does it come from? To achieve net zero carbon emissions politicians will have to make some difficult decisions about how we power our lives and the economy. John and Rachel talk to Professor Dieter Helm, Britain’s leading energy economist, to get a sense of the scale of the challenge.
Guest: Dieter Helm, professor of energy policy at New College, Oxford
Hosts: John Curtice and Rachel Wolf
To find out more about Tortoise:
- Download the Tortoise app - for a listening experience curated by our journalists
- Subscribe to Tortoise+ on Apple Podcasts for early access and exclusive content
- Become a member and get access to all of Tortoise's premium audio offerings and more
If you want to get in touch with us directly about a story, or tell us more about the stories you want to hear about trendy@tortoisemedia.com