Elasticsearch is open source, again (Changelog Interviews #614)
Oct 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Shay Banon, the creator of Elasticsearch and founder of Elastic, reveals the fascinating journey back to open-source. He discusses the complexities of open-source licensing and trademark law that led to their previous switch to a more restrictive model. The conversation digs into Amazon renaming its product to OpenSearch and the significance of branding in the open-source realm. Banon also highlights the emotional challenges the company faced and the broader impact on community perception and sustainability in the tech world.
Elastic's decision to revert to an AGPL license highlights the complex dynamics of open source licensing amid corporate interests and community backlash.
The trademark dispute with Amazon significantly influenced Elastic's strategy, as it emphasized the importance of brand identity in a competitive landscape.
Shea Banon's emphasis on community collaboration illustrates how open source projects thrive on user engagement and collective innovation for future development.
Deep dives
Return to Open Source
Elastic's return to open source represents a significant shift in their strategy, initiated by the decision to revert to an AGPL license after a period of embracing non-OSI-approved licenses. This change comes after a tumultuous four years marked by a trademark dispute with Amazon over Elasticsearch, which ultimately necessitated the license change in the first place. The founder, Shea Banon, deeply values open source and believes that increasing its presence can benefit the community and the ecosystem at large. The move back to open source aims to reconnect Elastic with its core values and better serve a community that thrives on collaboration and accessibility.
Implications of Licensing Changes
The discussion highlights the complexities of open source licensing, especially in relation to corporate interests. When Elastic changed its license initially to combat market confusion with AWS's use of the Elasticsearch name, it faced backlash from the community due to the loss of open source status. However, despite the licensing changes, usage of Elasticsearch continued to grow, demonstrating a disconnect between the open source designation and actual user behavior. Banon reflects on the emotional and professional difficulty of that decision and its long-term impacts on their brand and community trust.
Trademark and Market Confusion
The trademark dispute with Amazon significantly influenced Elastic's strategy, as it blurred the lines between their product and Amazon's service. Shea Banon explained that the frustration originated not from Amazon providing Elastic as a service, which is legal under open source licenses, but from the confusion generated by their branding that misled users. This brand confusion made it challenging for Elastic to establish its market presence and consumer recognition, effectively stifling its growth potential. By shifting to the AGPL license and removing Amazon's control over the Elasticsearch name, Elastic aims to clarify its brand identity in the competitive landscape.
The Future of Open Source and Cloud
Shea Banon noted that the landscape for open source and cloud technologies is evolving, particularly with the rise of artificial intelligence and vector databases. Elastic aims to position itself as a leader in this space by improving its offerings to include advanced search and semantic capabilities while maintaining ease of use for developers. The emphasis on user-friendly design and integration of new features aims to facilitate the adoption of Elastic's solutions in emerging technologies. As more companies grapple with the implications of cloud service providers appropriating open source software, Elastic's careful navigation of these issues could influence future trends in the industry.
Community and Collaboration
The podcast emphasizes the crucial role of community in shaping the future of open source projects. Shea Banon shared insights on how the response from the open source community to their return has been overwhelmingly positive, with many members expressing gratitude for the decision. The collaborative spirit inherent in open source drives innovation and allows users to contribute meaningfully, while Elastic hopes to cultivate this spirit by reinforcing its commitment to open collaborations. Encouraging greater participation in the future design and direction of the software aligns with Elastic's mission to expand accessibility and engagement in the development process.
Shay Banon, the creator of Elasticsearch, joins us to discuss pulling off a reverse rug pull. Yes, Elasticsearch is open source, again! We discuss the complexities surrounding open source licensing and what made Elastic change their license, the implications of trademark law, the personal and business impact of moving away from open source, and ultimately what made them hit rewind and return to open source.
Changelog++ members save 10 minutes on this episode because they made the ads disappear. Join today!
Sponsors:
Fly.io – The home of Changelog.com — Deploy your apps close to your users — global Anycast load-balancing, zero-configuration private networking, hardware isolation, and instant WireGuard VPN connections. Push-button deployments that scale to thousands of instances. Check out the speedrun to get started in minutes.
Speakeasy – Production-ready, enterprise-resilient, best-in-class SDKs crafted in minutes. Speakeasy takes care of the entire SDK workflow to save you significant time, delivering SDKs to your customers in minutes with just a few clicks! Create your first SDK for free!
AssemblyAI – Turn voice data into summaries with AssemblyAI’s leading Speech AI models. Built by AI experts, their Speech AI models include accurate speech-to-text for voice data (such as calls, virtual meetings, and podcasts), speaker detection, sentiment analysis, chapter detection, PII redaction, and more.
Wix Studio – Wix Sudio is for devs who build websites, sell apps, go headless, or manage clients. Integrate, extend and write custom scripts in a VS code-based IDE. Leverage zero set up dev, test and production environments. Ship faster with an AI code assistant. And work with Wix headless API’s on any tech stack.
