Paul Kingsnorth, a writer and former leading environmentalist, shares his transformative journey from radical activism to a simpler, faith-driven lifestyle in rural Ireland. He critiques the modern Green Movement's shift toward commercial interests, emphasizing the spiritual loss embedded in technological progress. Kingsnorth discusses the challenge of navigating contemporary life, advocating for a return to community and nature. He explores the implications of secular ideologies on identity, while seeking hope and meaning in a rapidly changing world.
Paul Kingsnorth's shift from radical environmentalism to embracing Christianity highlights the importance of spiritual fulfillment and connection with nature.
Kingsnorth's critique of modernity challenges the dominance of secular values and emphasizes the spiritual void in contemporary culture.
The secular narrative of individual freedom and autonomy is questioned for its potential to erode social cohesion and undermine transcendent meaning.
Capitalism is criticized for prioritizing profit over community well-being and environmental sustainability, with its religious-like pursuit of technological advancement.
Deep dives
Shift in Personal Beliefs
The personal transformation of Paul Kingsnorth from a radical environmentalist and activist to a more spiritual and religious individual is highlighted. After experiencing a profound shift in his beliefs, he moved away from his previous ideologies and embraced a more traditional and spiritual way of life in rural Ireland, focusing on living simply and connecting with nature. This transformation was not a sudden event but rather a gradual process marked by a series of experiences and realizations that led him to explore a different path.
Religious Encounters and Inspirations
Paul Kingsnorth's journey towards embracing Christianity was influenced by key experiences, including a vivid dream of Jesus and prophetic messages from people he encountered. Despite his initial resistance to Christianity and association with other spiritual practices like Zen Buddhism and nature worship, Paul's encounters and experiences ultimately led him to accept Christianity, recognizing a spiritual void that he believes was filled by a connection to God through Christ. These encounters were marked by a deep spiritual awakening and a profound sense of revelation.
Critique of Modernity and Secularism
The podcast delves into Paul Kingsnorth's critique of modernity and the secular values that dominate Western society. He challenges the prevalent secular narratives of progress, individualism, and materialism, suggesting that the rejection of traditional beliefs and the pursuit of technological advancement have left a spiritual void in contemporary culture. Kingsnorth explores the impact of secular ideologies on societal values and highlights the allure of science, self-indulgence, and individualism as replacements for traditional notions of community, faith, and interconnectedness.
Exploration of Liberalism and the Secular Story
A critical analysis of liberalism and the secular narrative is presented, emphasizing the overarching philosophy of individual freedom, empowerment, and autonomy within contemporary Western societies. Paul Kingsnorth articulates how the modern secular story revolves around liberating individuals from traditional structures, beliefs, and constraints, encouraging self-definition and self-expression. However, he warns of the unintended consequences of this secular liberation, noting that it can lead to a breakdown of social cohesion, identity crises, and a lack of transcendent meaning or purpose in people's lives.
Shift Towards Traditional Values and Christian Faith
Paul Kingsnorth discusses how his political views shifted towards traditionalism and a deeper appreciation for values that modern society has eroded, emphasizing the importance of family, community, connection with nature, and religion. His journey into Orthodox Christianity has influenced his writing, leading him to explore themes of identity, tradition, and faith, focusing on the interconnectedness of people, place, and prayer.
Critique of Capitalism and Technological Progress
Paul Kingsnorth critiques capitalism as a system deliberately constructed by power structures, highlighting its destructive impact on communities and the environment. He delves into the religious undertones of technological advancement, emphasizing how big tech's goals mirror a quest to build or replace God. Kingsnorth advocates for defining human flourishing beyond material progress, highlighting the trade-offs and losses that come with technological innovation.
Hope Through Christian Faith and Easter Celebration
Easter symbolizes hope and renewal in Kingsnorth's Orthodox Christian faith, transcending despair and reminding believers of the transformative power of faith. He describes Easter as a time of deepening spiritual journey, where the resurrection story redefines perceptions of the world and sustains a steady, unwavering hope. Kingsnorth's celebration of Easter underscores the enduring significance of faith in navigating life's challenges and uncertainties.
If the First Industrial Revolution used water and steam to fundamentally change the nature of work, the current industrial revolution—the disruption of automation, information, the internet, and now AI—is transforming everything about the way we work, connect, and interact with the natural world.
These changes have largely been regarded as a net good. After all, poverty across the world has fallen precipitously in the last 100 years. Life expectancy has nearly doubled. Literacy is four times higher. Hunger, malnutrition, war—all down. All good things.
But today’s guest, writer Paul Kingsnorth, thinks that the way in which this progress has been achieved is detrimental not only to the environment but to our own mental and physical well-being—and that underneath the extreme wealth built by human society is a massive sense of human and spiritual loss.
Paul is someone who has gone through a profound transformation over the past decade, and in a very public way. He was once considered one of the West’s most radical and prominent environmentalists—even chaining himself to a bridge in protest of road construction and leading The Ecologist, a left-wing environmental magazine. But he became disillusioned with an environmental movement that he says became obsessed with cutting carbon emissions by any means, and getting captured by commercial interests in the process.
Paul and his family eventually left urban England to live off the land in rural Ireland, where they currently grow their own food and the children are homeschooled.
One more thing of note this Easter week: Paul converted from a practicing Buddhist and Wiccan to an Orthodox Christian—which is about as traditional as it gets.
As you’ll hear in this conversation, Paul explains why he intentionally “regressed.” In short: in our modern, hyper-connected, tech-obsessed world—what he calls “the age of the machine”—Paul and his family are trying to live wildly. We talk about what that looks like for him, and for any of us trying to be free; we talk about how the left has strayed from its original principles; why the West has abandoned God; and how to fight every day to live. . . simply.
