Sam Harris speaks with philosopher David Chalmers about the nature of consciousness, the challenges of understanding it scientifically, and the prospect of building it into machines. They discuss the hard problem of consciousness, the notion of consciousness as integrated information, and the possibility of living in a simulation. They also explore non-reductive explanations of consciousness, AI safety concerns, and the need to prepare for the implications of superintelligent AI.
The concept of zombies is used to illustrate the challenge of understanding consciousness scientifically.
The theories of epiphenomenalism, information integration theory, and panpsychism are explored as possible explanations for the relationship between consciousness and physical processes in the brain.
The limitations of available evidence make the study of consciousness challenging, as direct evidence of consciousness is often absent.
Innovative approaches and methodologies are needed to unravel the mysteries of consciousness.
Deep dives
David Chalmers and Sam Harris discuss consciousness and the hard problem
In this podcast, David Chalmers and Sam Harris dive into the topic of consciousness. They discuss the hard problem of consciousness, which is the challenge of explaining why and how subjective experience arises. Chalmers introduces the concept of zombies, beings that behave like humans but lack any conscious experience, to illustrate the difficulty in understanding consciousness scientifically. They explore different theories, including epiphenomenalism and information integration theory, as possible explanations for the relationship between consciousness and physical processes in the brain. Additionally, they delve into the idea of panpsychism, the notion that consciousness may be a fundamental aspect of reality at even the most basic levels. The conversation highlights the deep mysteries surrounding consciousness and the ongoing exploration to understand its nature.
The challenges of explaining consciousness scientifically
Chalmers and Harris explore the difficulties in explaining consciousness scientifically. The conversation acknowledges that while there are proven correlations between certain brain processes and conscious experiences, there is still a fundamental gap in understanding why subjective experience arises from physical processes. They discuss the limitations of behaviorism and the need to go beyond behavioral explanations to truly grasp consciousness. The concept of a consciousness meter is mentioned as a hypothetical tool that could provide direct evidence of consciousness, but its lack of practicality demonstrates the complexities and limitations of studying consciousness.
Different theories and perspectives on consciousness
Chalmers and Harris delve into different theories and perspectives surrounding consciousness. They touch upon epiphenomenalism, the idea that consciousness is a byproduct that does not have any causative effect on behavior. Information integration theory is also discussed, which suggests that conscious experience arises from the integration of information in the brain. The concept of panpsychism is explored, proposing that consciousness may exist at the most fundamental level of reality. While these theories offer potential insights into consciousness, they are acknowledged to still leave many questions unanswered.
The limitations of evidence in studying consciousness
Chalmers and Harris shed light on the challenges associated with studying consciousness due to the limitations of available evidence. They acknowledge that first-person experiences provide subjective evidence for individual consciousness, but when it comes to other beings and systems, the evidence becomes indirect and subjective. The absence of direct evidence prompts discussions on whether consciousness can be scientifically studied and if theories should rely on indirect or circumstantial evidence. The elusive nature of consciousness calls for innovative approaches and methodologies to unravel its mysteries.
The Limitations of Human Cognitive Ability
Human cognitive abilities can sometimes be limited, as demonstrated by the speaker's personal experience of struggling to spell a simple word. This suggests that there may be phenomena and concepts that are difficult for us to understand due to our cognitive deficits.
Exploring the Nature of Consciousness
Consciousness is considered a hard problem to explain through standard physical processes. The speaker argues that consciousness cannot be fully understood in terms of current scientific knowledge and that new properties or a whole new approach may be needed to study consciousness effectively.
The Implications of Artificial Intelligence
The development of artificial intelligence poses significant ethical concerns. The speaker discusses the potential consequences and dilemmas surrounding AI, including the possibility of creating conscious AI systems that may have different ethical significance and the challenges of preserving personal identity during the process of uploading human consciousness.
Sam Harris speaks with philosopher David Chalmers about the nature of consciousness, the challenges of understanding it scientifically, and the prospect that we will one day build it into our machines.
David Chalmers is Professor of Philosophy and co-director of the Center for Mind, Brain, and Consciousness at New York University, and also holds a part-time position at the Australian National University. He is well-known for his work in the philosophy of mind, especially for his formulation of the “hard problem” of consciousness. His 1996 book The Conscious Mind: In Search of a Fundamental Theory was successful with both popular and academic audiences. Chalmers co-founded the Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness and has organized some of the most important conferences in the field. He also works on many other issues in philosophy and cognitive science, and has articles on the possibility of a “singularity” in artificial intelligence and on philosophical issues arising from the movie The Matrix.
Episodes that have been re-released as part of the Best of Making Sense series may have been edited for relevance since their original airing.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
