Mic Drop: Australia’s attempt to keep kids off social media
Jan 24, 2025
auto_awesome
John Pane, a privacy advocate at Electronic Frontiers Australia, discusses Australia's controversial social media age-gating aimed at keeping kids under 16 offline. He argues this plan poses risks not only to youth privacy but also to broader human rights. Pane highlights the ineffectiveness of age verification methods and warns about the potential increase in surveillance. He emphasizes the importance of balancing child safety with privacy rights, raising alarms about how such regulations could impact marginalized communities.
Australia's age-gating law aims to protect kids under 16 from social media, yet raises significant privacy concerns about surveillance methods.
Critics argue that despite the law's intention to safeguard youth mental health, it may not effectively deter children from social media usage.
Deep dives
Australia's Strict Surveillance Law
Australia has enacted one of the strictest surveillance laws globally, known as TOLA, which mandates technology companies to create back doors for law enforcement access. This law allows the government to impose a social media ban for children under 16, aiming to combat the perceived harms of social media on youth mental health. Critics argue that the ban may not effectively deter children from using social platforms or foster their return to traditional outdoor activities. The law raises concerns about its implementation and the potential for infringing on privacy rights, as it centralizes authority with the communications minister to determine which platforms the ban applies to.
Concerns About Youth Mental Health and Social Media
Growing apprehension regarding social media's impact on youth mental health has led to stronger advocacy for protective measures. Key figures like Jonathan Haidt have highlighted the negative effects of smartphones on children's attention spans and overall well-being, igniting fears among parents. Despite pushback from some researchers who argue that the effects of technology are not as straightforward as suggested, the visible consequences have prompted significant legislative action. This societal shift mirrors past movements aimed at enhancing safety regulations, reminiscent of efforts to improve automotive safety during the late 20th century.
Challenges of Verifying Age Online
The enforcement of the new law raises substantial questions regarding the verification of age for social media users, particularly given the diverse methods proposed for compliance. Options like biometrics and automated analysis of online behavior pose risks to privacy and could lead to a culture of surveillance. Critics caution that such measures could disproportionately harm marginalized youth and infringe upon their rights. The law's effectiveness hinges on not only the methodology of age verification but also the understanding of the underlying issues youth face online, suggesting a potential disconnect between legislative intent and real-world outcomes.
Australia is trying to use age-gating to keep kids under 16 off social media. John Pane, at Electronic Frontiers Australia, is worried that kids won’t be the only people losing something. He says privacy as we know it is also in the crosshairs.