The Science (and Pseudoscience) of Gender | Peter Boghossian & Colin Wright
Sep 15, 2023
auto_awesome
Evolutionary biologist Colin Wright and Peter Boghossian discuss the impact of gender ideology on public discourse and debunk misconceptions about gender and sex. They explore the limitations of binary concepts of sex, the influence of sociology on beliefs, and the ability of anthropologists to determine the biological sex of a skeleton. They also address the shift in behavior and beliefs of YouTube atheists and the backlash faced when defending biological reality.
Recognizing sex as a binary construct is essential for fairness in areas like sports where biological advantages impact competition.
Conflating gender and biological sex erases the significance of biological differences between males and females.
Engaging in open and honest dialogue is necessary to address the challenges of discussing gender identity and foster meaningful conversations.
Deep dives
The importance of understanding sex as a binary
The podcast episode discusses the importance of recognizing sex as a binary construct and the consequences of blurring the lines between sex and gender. The guest, Colin Wright, emphasizes that while there are many ways that males and females can differ in terms of physical traits and characteristics, the fundamental distinction lies in their ability to produce different types of gametes. He argues that categorizing individuals based on biological sex is vital for maintaining fairness in areas such as sports, where biological advantages can significantly impact competition.
The confusion surrounding gender and sex
The podcast episode highlights the ongoing confusion and debates surrounding the definitions of gender and sex. The guest, Colin Wright, critiques the idea that gender is completely separate from and unrelated to biological sex. He suggests that conflation of the two terms can lead to erasing the significance of biological differences between males and females. Additionally, he challenges the notion that gender identity can override biological sex, asserting that it is important to maintain clear distinctions based on biological reality.
The challenges of discussing gender identity
The podcast episode explores the challenges of discussing gender identity and its impact on society. The guest, Colin Wright, addresses the difficulties in engaging in conversations with individuals who hold rigid beliefs about gender and who prioritize personal identity over objective biological distinctions. He highlights the need for open and honest dialogue, encouraging individuals to express their beliefs openly and honestly to foster meaningful discussions on topics related to gender and identity.
The Impact of Gender Ideology
Gender ideology is not an obscure argument, but something that has a significant impact on society. The denial of biological sex and the adoption of gender identity can have far-reaching consequences. One example is the controversy surrounding transgender athletes competing in women's sports, which calls into question the fairness and integrity of athletic competition. This ideology can also lead to drastic measures, such as gender-affirming surgeries for minors. It is crucial to defend the reality of biological sex and address the negative implications of gender ideology.
Challenging Pronouns and Skeletal Differences
The use of preferred pronouns is controversial, with some arguing that it perpetuates an ideology that disconnects gender from biological sex. While some individuals may choose to use gender-neutral pronouns, others believe in respecting pronouns within certain limits, particularly for individuals who are not delusional about their biological sex. On the topic of skeletal differences between males and females, experts can discern the sex of a skeleton with near certainty based on various skeletal features affected by male puberty. Denying these biological differences or promoting the idea of a blank slate morphology is seen as undermining fundamental aspects of human biology.
Evolutionary biologist Colin Wright is the founding editor of Reality's Last Stand, a publication dedicated to free speech, science, and reality. His articles on sex and gender have been published in The Wall Street Journal, The Times, New York Post, Newsweek, City Journal, Quillette, and other major news outlets and peer-reviewed journals.
Colin is a Manhattan Institute Fellow, an Academic Advisor at the Society for Evidence-Based Gender Medicine (SEGM), and a member of Genspect’s Killarney Group.
Colin received a Ph.D. in evolutionary biology from UC Santa Barbara in 2018. He left academia in 2020 when the fervor of gender ideology became an obstacle to scientific inquiry and free speech.