Matt Slater, a football reporter for The Athletic, delves into the complexities of multi-club ownership in football. He discusses its effectiveness and future, examining financial dynamics and player opportunities. The impact on club identity and fan loyalty is also a key topic. Slater sheds light on how entities like the City Football Group manage diverse clubs and reflects on the distinct challenges faced by clubs like Olympique Lyonnais. Expect insights on navigating the balance between commercialization and maintaining genuine connections with fans.
Multi-club ownership models allow for resource sharing and talent development, but their effectiveness and sustainability remain uncertain.
Fan loyalty is challenged by the financial motives behind multi-club ownerships, potentially straining relationships between clubs and their supporters.
Deep dives
The Appeal of Multi-Club Ownership (MCO)
Multi-club ownership (MCO) models have become a significant trend in modern football, attracting attention for their potential benefits. The strategy often allows larger clubs to harness resources from smaller affiliated clubs, creating a network of talent and financial support. For example, clubs can share scouting networks, training resources, and even players, aiming to enhance player development and optimize transfer strategies. However, the effectiveness of these networks is still under scrutiny, and the long-term sustainability of MCOs remains unproven.
Challenges Faced by Leicester City's MCO Model
Concerns regarding Leicester City's MCO approach illustrate some of the potential pitfalls associated with these ownership structures. Fans raised questions about how the club has benefited from its relationship with O.H. Leuven, a Belgian club within the same ownership group, especially when Leicester's youth players often struggle for playing time there. Recruitment issues and lack of coherent strategy appear problematic, as players like Kamel Sowah didn't successfully transition through the network. This case exemplifies uncertainties tied to MCOs, highlighting the need for clearer strategies to leverage relationships effectively.
Profitability and the Value of MCOs
Evaluating the financial viability of MCOs reveals a complex picture, as many clubs struggle to turn consistent profits. Despite significant investments and operational losses, the value of club assets has tended to increase over time, suggesting a long-term strategy focused on asset appreciation rather than immediate profitability. The City Football Group exemplifies this, reporting considerable losses across its 13 clubs while simultaneously observing increasing valuations of their assets. This raises questions about whether owners prioritize short-term gains or view clubs primarily as long-term investments, comparable to real estate.
Fan Sentiments and the Future of MCOs
As MCOs shape the football landscape, fan perspectives play a critical role in shaping the discourse surrounding this model. Fans often grapple with their loyalty to their club versus the overarching ownership structure and potential prioritization of more profitable clubs within the network. The relationship between clubs and their supporters may become strained as ownership groups make decisions based on financial rather than local interests. Ultimately, as football fans confront the changes MCOs bring, it becomes vital for these groups to balance financial goals with the community-focused values that deeply resonate with supporters.
This is the third and final part of our multi-club ownership series.
We’ve learned how multi-club operations work and provided some practical examples from the world of football.
Today - we answer your questions on the effectiveness and future of MCOs.
So, can we say for certain multi-club ownership is here to stay?
Host: Ayo Akinwolere
With: Matt Slater
Executive Producer: Adey Moorhead
Producer: Mike Stavrou
We want to hear about your podcast habits. Go to theathletic.com/athletic/survey25 to fill out a short survey and be in with the chance of winning £/$100 Amazon vouchers