Michael Mann, Professor of Sociology Emeritus at the University of California, Los Angeles, discusses the irrationality of war and challenges the rational aspect of war-making states. Topics include the conflict in Israel-Palestine, the Russian-Ukraine war, the role of the state in causing war, religious differences, American involvement in wars, and the current state of military violence.
Wars are often the result of miscalculations by over-confident rulers with little regard for their own people.
Religious convictions and a lust for revenge can drive wars.
Deep dives
Key Point 1: The fascination with war and the motivation behind writing the book
The author discusses his fascination with war and the motivation behind writing the book. He explains that his previous work focused on military power, but he wanted to delve deeper into the causes of wars and the irrationality behind them. He found that wars are mainly irrational and rarely produce positive results.
Key Point 2: Rivalry and conflict in Israel and Palestine
The author explores the complex conflict between Israel and Palestine, highlighting the multiple wars happening simultaneously in the region. He emphasizes the religious and territorial differences as driving factors, with both sides claiming divine right to the land. He also discusses the impact of extremist ideologies and emotions like hatred and revenge in fueling the conflict.
Key Point 3: The Russian-Ukrainian war and territorial disputes
The author examines the war between Russia and Ukraine, noting the territorial disputes and the desire of Putin to re-establish the Russian Empire. He highlights the mixture of rational and irrational motives behind the conflict, including security concerns and a desire for domination. The author also mentions the role of racial stereotypes and underestimation of the Ukrainian people in shaping Russian aggression.
Key Point 4: America's predisposition to war and the role of leaders
The author reflects on America's involvement in various wars, questioning the predisposition to war in American culture. He suggests that wars are primarily initiated by rulers rather than the general populace, emphasizing the role of leaders' decisions in starting and perpetuating conflicts. He also mentions the challenges of predicting the outcomes of wars and the potential for mistakes and miscalculations.
“Irrationality rules” in war, Michael Mann writes in his magisterial 2023 book, On Wars(Yale UP, 2023), a history that begins with the Roman Republic and ancient China and works its way through the world wars of the 20th century and up to present times. Mann is a Professor of Sociology Emeritus at the University of California, Los Angeles. His irrationality thesis, which posits that many wars are the product of miscalculations by over-confident rulers with little regard for their own people, offers an insightful and persuasive challenge to the Realist school on war, which stresses a rational aspect to the designs of war-making states. Then, too, Mann notes, wars can be driven by religious convictions and by a lust for revenge. Our conversation touches on the conflict in Israel-Palestine reignited by the Hamas massacre of Israeli civilians in October, 2023 as well as on the ongoing Russian-Ukraine war launched by Vladimir Putin in February, 2022.
Veteran journalist Paul Starobin is a former Moscow bureau chief for Business Week and a former contributing editor of The Atlantic. He has written for The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal and many other publications. His latest book, Putin’s Exiles: Their Fight for a Better Russia (Columbia Global Reports) will be published in January.