CNLP 699 | Zach Zehnder on What's Wrong in Current Discipleship, Planting a Church In a Mainline Denomination, and How to Know When It's Time to Leave
Dec 31, 2024
auto_awesome
Zach Zehnder, a Lutheran pastor and author, discusses the flaws in current discipleship practices and his experiences planting a church in a mainline denomination. He emphasizes the need for deeper commitments to Jesus amidst modern challenges and the disconnect between church growth metrics and authentic faith development. Zach also shares insights on knowing when to transition away from pastoral roles and highlights the importance of supportive networks in church planting. Their conversation dives into personality dynamics that enhance collaboration in ministry.
Current discipleship within churches often emphasizes leadership development over true imitation of Christ, leading to a gap in genuine faith practice.
A cohesive understanding of discipleship is lacking among church leaders, resulting in varied interpretations that hinder effective disciple-making initiatives.
Balancing church leadership with family life is crucial for pastors, and effective time management and communication can prevent burnout and maintain well-being.
Deep dives
The Ineffectiveness of Current Discipleship
Current discipleship efforts within the church are often lacking, leading to a significant gap between professed faith and genuine following of Jesus. Many believers today merely identify as Christians while struggling to embody the essence of discipleship that Jesus calls for. A major issue lies in the emphasis on leadership development over discipleship pathways, resulting in church leaders being trained more to lead than to follow Christ effectively. Recognizing that discipleship should involve a commitment to imitating Jesus is crucial for producing authentic followers who can then inspire others.
Discipleship and Leadership: A Call for Clarity
There's a pressing need for clarity in defining what discipleship truly means within church circles. The podcast emphasizes that many church leaders struggle to articulate a cohesive understanding of discipleship, leading to varied interpretations that can hinder effective practice. Discipleship should encapsulate both being and doing as a follower of Christ, pointing toward a simple but often neglected call to model one's life after Jesus. To foster a more robust discipleship culture, churches must focus on actionable steps that align closely with Jesus's teachings and commands.
The Impact of Disconnection on Faith Communities
When discipleship is not prioritized, both individual followers and faith communities face detrimental effects, including confusion and disillusionment about what it means to follow Christ. This lack of clear discipleship leads to a collective representation of Christ that feels indistinguishable from non-believers, which is concerning for witnessing efforts. On a personal level, this gap can be emotionally damaging, resulting in guilt and shame for leaders who recognize the importance of disciple-making but feel unprepared to achieve it. The ramifications highlight the importance of getting discipleship right, as it directly impacts both individual faith journeys and the collective church witness.
Shifting Dynamics in Church Engagement Post-COVID
The pandemic exposed significant gaps in the discipleship of many Christians, revealing a stark difference between mere belief and active following of Jesus. Despite a growing emphasis on discipleship discussions, many individuals have become increasingly polarized and less reflective of the fruits of the Spirit. Key themes emerging from the conversation suggest that while believers maintain their identity in Christ, they often miss out on embodying the transformative aspects of discipleship in their daily lives. To address this, faith communities must guide followers toward a deeper commitment to living out their faith practically and relationally.
Balancing Leadership and Family Life
Navigating the demands of church leadership while maintaining family life can be a complex endeavor for many pastors. The conversation covers the importance of seeking balance through counseling and prayerful reflection to ensure that leaders do not neglect their personal relationships. Implementing practical time management strategies, such as prioritizing and setting healthy boundaries, is essential to avoid burnout and maintain a productive leadership style. Fostering communication with spouses about roles and expectations can also play a critical role in sustaining a healthy work-life balance.
What's wrong with the current approach to discipleship? Lutheran pastor and author Zach Zehnder talks about what's wrong with the current approach to discipleship and what it's like to plant a church in a mainline denomination.
Plus, Carey and Zach discuss the challenges of being an entrepreneurial pastor and how these innovative church leaders know when it's time to leave their clergy positions.
If you want to be the first to get 2025's church trends, be sure to join my email list — on January 2nd, I'll be releasing all 5 trends along with a leader guide, and throughout January, there'll be more church trends content, podcast episodes, and resources to come.
You're invited to get access to all the latest State of the Church research from Barna. You’ll get free updates on monthly research drops, trending topics, and important news from across the Church–all powered by Gloo.