Judging Freedom [SPECIAL] ZeroHedge Debate - America First on Trial — Dave Smith vs. Dinesh D’Souza
Jan 15, 2026
In a thought-provoking debate, Dave Smith, a libertarian comedian known for his sharp non-interventionist views, faces off against Dinesh D'Souza, a conservative author advocating for a robust U.S. foreign policy. They discuss the essence of 'America First,' contrasting non-interventionism with what D'Souza sees as necessary realism. Topics include the outcomes of U.S. interventions, the impact of supporting Israel, and the limits of presidential war powers. Their engaging exchange sheds light on differing philosophies about America's role in global affairs.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
America First As Non‑Intervention
- 'America First' historically means non‑interventionism and opposing regime‑change wars.
- Dave Smith argues Trump abandoned that tradition by returning to hawkish policies.
America First As Realist Balance
- Dinesh D'Souza frames America First as realism balancing ideals and national interests.
- He argues a powerful state must sometimes intervene to protect values and prevent rivals from displacing the U.S.
War Authorization And Constitutional Limits
- Dave Smith warns interventions regularly produce catastrophic outcomes and constitutional violations.
- He insists Congress must authorize non‑defensive wars under the Constitution.
