The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Instant REACTION to Arch Manning's debut and OSU taking down Texas
Aug 31, 2025
Arch Manning faced intense pressure during his debut, struggling to meet high expectations while Texas succumbed to Ohio State's formidable defense. The analysis delves into coaching strategies and how they shaped this key matchup. The NIL era is transforming recruitment dynamics, making it harder for smaller programs to retain talent. Meanwhile, the Buckeyes solidified their strength in the Big Ten, raising questions about Texas's future in the SEC. It's a whirlwind look at the highs and lows of college football this season.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Hype Requires On-Field Validation
- John Middlecoff argues Arch Manning's debut exposed excessive hype that didn't match on-field performance.
- He says football hype must be validated by game play, not media narratives.
Calm A Rattled Quarterback Fast
- Do calm and dial in a hyped quarterback before big conference games to avoid basic errors.
- Build simple, high-percentage passing early to restore confidence and sustain drives.
Play-Calling Depends On QB Execution
- Middlecoff emphasizes play-calling is hamstrung when a quarterback can't make basic throws.
- He credits Sarkeesian's play design but notes it's limited by errant QB execution.