SGEM#487: Tell Me How I’m Supposed to Breathe with No Air? Nasal High Flow or Standard Care for Pediatric Intubation

Reference:  George S, et al. Effectiveness of nasal high-flow oxygen during apnoea on hypoxaemia and intubation success in paediatric emergency and ICU settings: a randomised, controlled, open-label trial. Lancet Respir Med. March 2025 Date: July 10, 2025 Guest Skeptic: Dr. Spyridon Karageorgos is a Pediatric Chief Resident at Aghia Sophia Children’s Hospital, Athens, Greece and faculty of the Pediatric Emergency Medicine MSc at Queen Mary University in London. Case: A two-year-old boy presents in the emergency department (ED) with severe respiratory distress and hypoxemia. You attempt to use some non-invasive forms of respiratory support, but he continues to have significant work of breathing and retractions. His mental status begins to decline, and he appears much sleepier than before. The team makes the decision to intubate him. You follow the steps of the pre-intubation checklist and pre-oxygenate him with 100% FiO2. As the sedative and paralytic for intubation are given, the respiratory therapist asks, “Do you also want to use nasal high flow (NHF) for apneic oxygenation during intubation?”  Background: Managing hypoxia in pediatric patients in EDs and intensive care units (ICUs) remains a challenge. Hypoxia can arise from various causes, including bronchiolitis, pneumonia, asthma, or undifferentiated respiratory failure. Ensuring timely and effective oxygenation is critical to stabilizing these patients and preventing progression to respiratory failure or cardiac arrest.  NHF oxygenation has gained traction as a respiratory support modality in both ED and ICU settings. NHF delivers humidified and heated oxygen at high flow rates, which typically exceed the patient’s inspiratory flow through nasal cannula. This mechanism not only improves oxygenation but can also help reduce the work of breathing by flushing anatomical dead space and providing some degree of positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP). The use of NHF is considered less invasive than continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) or bilevel positive airway pressure (BiPAP) or mechanical ventilation. It is usually better tolerated, especially by children. The use of NHF has expanded into general pediatric practice, especially for treating conditions like bronchiolitis and other forms of acute respiratory distress. But, its comparative efficacy to standard oxygen therapy in various clinical settings and patient populations remains a subject of ongoing investigation. While we would always prefer a controlled intubation, sometimes the patients we see in the ED are unstable and need to be intubated emergently. We often try to pre-oxygenate prior to intubating to maximize oxygen reserves. Previous studies have suggested that the use of NHF may reduce the risk of hypoxemia and improve first-attempt intubation . However, randomized controlled trials evaluating this practice in the pediatric population are limited. Clinical Question: In children requiring emergency intubation, does the use of nasal high-flow oxygen for apneic oxygenation reduce hypoxemia and increase the rate of successful first-attempt intubation compared to standard care? Reference:  George S, et al. Effectiveness of nasal high-flow oxygen during apnoea on hypoxaemia and intubation success in paediatric emergency and ICU settings: a randomised, controlled, open-label trial. Lancet Respir Med. March 2025 Population: Children aged 1 month to 15 years with acute hypoxic respiratory failure (SpO₂ <92% on room air) requiring emergency endotracheal intubation in EDs and pediatric and neonatal ICUs across Australia, New Zealand, and Switzerland. Exclusion: Primary nasal intubation, blocked nasal airways, elective endotracheal tube change, intubation required immediately for loss of cardiac output or respiratory arrest, location of intubation outside of ED or ICU, death Intervention: Nasal high-flow oxygen at 2L/kg/min during the apneic phase of intubation....