The Last Word with Matt Cooper

Is De-Naming Public Property The Right Thing To Do?

Dec 1, 2025
Joining the discussion are Eoin O'Malley, an Associate Professor of Political Science at Dublin City University, and Dr. Mary McAuliffe, a historian and gender studies lecturer at University College Dublin. They dive into the controversy of de-naming Herzog Park, exploring how historical figures like Herzog resonate with modern politics. Eoin questions the fairness of judging figures by contemporary standards, while Mary emphasizes the implications of naming on narratives of dispossession. They also propose alternatives, advocating for a focus on gender-balanced memorialization.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Memorials Mirror Today's Politics

  • Public memorials reflect present-day politics more than neutral history.
  • Eoin O'Malley argues naming choices are judged by contemporary standards rather than fixed histories.
INSIGHT

Renaming Signals Present Values

  • Denaming doesn't erase the past but signals current political values.
  • Mary McAuliffe links calls to dename Herzog Park to contemporary support for Palestinians.
INSIGHT

Historical Comparisons Can Mislead

  • Comparing Irish independence to Israel's creation is historically fraught.
  • Mary McAuliffe warns the Nakba and Palestinian exile make the situations not equivalent.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app