Reporters Without Orders Ep 343: Assam citizenship test, Delhi air pollution
Oct 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Delve into the weather contrasts between Guwahati and Delhi, spotlighting a cyclone's silver lining amidst Delhi's pollution woes. Discover how a pivotal Supreme Court ruling shapes Assam's citizenship landscape and its tangled historical roots. Examine Delhi's year-round pollution challenges and rising open burning incidents, questioning the effectiveness of existing initiatives. Explore the complexities of vehicular emissions and the transition to electric transport, while also illuminating the dire humanitarian situation in Palestine and the significance of independent journalism.
The Supreme Court's reaffirmation of the 1971 cutoff date for citizenship in Assam offers vital protections for both Hindu and Muslim migrants, while igniting concerns about cultural identity among local populations.
Delhi's air quality crisis persists due to ineffective government initiatives and lack of coordination among agencies, necessitating a shift towards year-round, scientifically supported strategies to tackle pollution.
Deep dives
Supreme Court Ruling on Citizenship in Assam
The recent Supreme Court judgment on Section 6A of the Citizenship Act reaffirms March 24, 1971, as the cutoff date for determining citizenship in Assam, a decision that maintains the status quo. This ruling provides significant relief to many migrants, particularly both Hindu and Muslim refugees who arrived in Assam before the cutoff, as it protects their citizenship status. The judgment underscores longstanding anxieties among local Assamese populations regarding migration and its potential threats to cultural identity, a concern that fueled the 1979 Assam movement aimed at addressing these issues. However, it raises further complications, particularly with the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), which allows non-Muslim migrants to apply for citizenship until 2014, creating a perceived contradiction in the treatment of different migrant groups.
Political Reactions and Implications
Political reaction to the Supreme Court's decision has been widespread among various groups, with many Assamese nationalist parties and organizations expressing support for the ruling. Interestingly, the Assam government and the Indian central government both favor maintaining the 1971 cutoff date, revealing an unusual political alignment among traditionally dissenting groups. However, calls for re-verification of the National Register of Citizens (NRC) persist, as certain political entities believe that the existing NRC does not adequately exclude illegal migrants, particularly Muslims. This political maneuvering reveals ongoing tensions in Assam over issues of migration and identity, compounded by the demand from Assam's nationalist factions for a reevaluation of their foundational citizenship policies.
Delhi's Persistent Pollution Crisis
The air quality crisis in Delhi, particularly during October and November, remains a pressing issue despite government efforts to combat pollution through various initiatives and plans. Current approaches, such as the National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) and the odd-even vehicle restriction scheme, have not proven effective, with experts emphasizing a need for year-round strategies rather than temporary solutions. Data reveal that government initiatives targeting PM10 have not led to a reduction in particulate levels, raising questions about their scientific basis. Notably, vehicular emissions, contribute significantly to pollution levels, and measures such as better public transport and waste management systems are essential to address the root causes.
Systemic Failures in Pollution Management
A significant factor in the failure to adequately address pollution in Delhi is the lack of a coordinated approach among various government agencies, hindered by ongoing political tensions. Notably, the utilization of funds allocated for air pollution management has been poor, with reports indicating that only a fraction of the budget has been effectively used. This underutilization stems from the government's inability to devise scientifically backed initiatives, further compounding the air quality challenges faced by the city. Experts stress the importance of focusing on the major sources of pollution, such as vehicular emissions and waste burning, rather than relying on insufficient short-term fixes.
This week, host Pratyush Deep is joined by Scroll’s Rokibuz Zaman and Newslaundry’s Drishti Choudhary.
Rokibuz reported on the Supreme Court’s judgement upholding the constitutional validity of Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955 – a provision added exclusively for Assam. He says that the judgement upholds 1971 as the year of entry, which contradicts the government’s 2014 cut-off under the CAA.
Drishti’s report was on the Delhi administration’s efforts and failures in tackling air pollution. She explained the measures undertaken by the Delhi government and that despite spending crores of money and sanctioning extensive resources, the situation has worsened.