

Benatar on Bullshit | With Rebecca Tuvel
Dec 8, 2024
David Benatar, author of 'Very Practical Ethics,' joins philosopher Rebecca Tuvel to dissect the nature of bullshit. They explore whether bullshitters are aware of their deceit and categorize forms of bullshit found in academia and daily life. The duo discusses the ethics of calling out dishonesty, the tragedy of collective nonsense, and the tension between personal and social responsibility. They also delve into the role of satire and language in highlighting bullshit and strategies for navigating today's misinformation landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
The Monkey and the Lion
- David Benatar tells a joke about a monkey, a giraffe, an elephant, and a lion.
- The monkey's story changes depending on who he's talking to, illustrating how bullshit adapts to context.
Defining Bullshit
- Bullshit is a fuzzy concept, lacking clear-cut definitions.
- Philosophers like Harry Frankfurt and G.A. Cohen offer different perspectives, focusing on disregard for truth and unclarifiable unclarity, respectively.
Bullshit in the New York Times
- A New York Times article about Kamala Harris' mother's lab is given as an example of bullshit.
- Claims about respectful treatment of mice and a reversed gender hierarchy are deemed nonsensical in the context of animal experimentation.