Exploring the value of learning from bad art to generate new creative ideas and respect for the process. Emphasizing the significance of trusted partners for entrepreneurs, such as Shopify and Discover credit cards. Discussing the concepts of descriptive and prescriptive criticism in analyzing art. Exploring the analysis process for movies and plays and the importance of studying successful works to understand audience appeal. Exploring the impact of learning from bad art on connecting with the audience and discussing the book 'Let's Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste' by Karl Wilson.
26:11
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Learning from bad art can inspire new creative ideas and respect for the process.
Separating the purpose and execution of a work allows for deeper analysis of its success or failure.
Deep dives
Learning from Bad Art
One of the main insights from this podcast episode is the value of learning from bad art. The hosts discuss the fact that most art in any given field is typically not very good. However, instead of simply dismissing or ridiculing bad art, they suggest that it can be a source of inspiration and learning. The hosts give an example of a show they saw at the Edinburgh International Fringe Festival that was extremely bad. Instead of focusing on its flaws, they turned their attention to what they would have done differently and how they could create a better show. This experience of critically analyzing bad art and using it to generate ideas can be a valuable tool for creators.
Descriptive Criticism and Separating Execution from Purpose
The podcast also explores the concept of descriptive criticism and the importance of separating the purpose of a work from its execution. Descriptive criticism involves objectively describing the actual work of art in order to critique it more effectively. By understanding the artistic choices and intentions behind a work, one can better evaluate its success or failure. The hosts suggest that it is crucial to consider the thematic and conceptual aspects of the work separately from the execution, which involves the craft-level decisions and techniques employed. This approach allows for a deeper analysis of what a work is trying to achieve and how it goes about achieving it.
Learning from Successful Crap
The podcast also delves into the idea of learning from successful works that one personally dislikes or finds unimpressive. They point out that even though certain popular works may not align with personal tastes, there is still value in examining what makes them successful. For example, they discuss the musical Les Misérables, which has garnered immense popularity despite some criticism. One aspect they highlight is the way the songs in the musical can be combined and sung as a medley, creating a cohesive and memorable experience for the audience. This ability to connect with the audience and reinforce the musical's themes and melodies is a craft-level aspect that contributes to its success. By studying examples of successful works, one can gain insights into what resonates with audiences and apply those lessons in their own creative endeavors.
For this week’s episode of Working Overtime, hosts June Thomas and Isaac Butler acknowledge the painful fact that most art is in fact pretty bad. Yet, just because the play, or painting was poorly constructed does not mean you have to scrub it from your mind. Thinking about how you might have improved the piece, or realizing it was made from a labor of love can often generate new creative ideas of your own and respect for the process.
Do you have a question about creative work? Leave a message at (304) 933-9675 or email us at working@slate.com.
Podcast production by Kevin Bendis and Cameron Drews.