The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 1 - Defending Jalen Hurts, how good is Arch Manning?, the Browns trade away Kenny Pickett, James Palmer
Aug 26, 2025
James Palmer, NFL analyst and reporter for the NFL Network, joins the conversation about Jalen Hurts, defending his status as an elite quarterback. They examine the hype surrounding Arch Manning as he prepares for a critical matchup against Ohio State. The episode also discusses the implications of Kenny Pickett's trade from the Browns and the evolving strategies regarding young quarterbacks in the league. With insights on team dynamics and player health, this insightful chat navigates the exciting landscape of the NFL.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Hurts Is Undervalued Because He's 'Boring'
- Jason McIntyre argues Jalen Hurts is undervalued despite historic dual-threat performance and a Super Bowl MVP.
- He suggests media bias toward flash and celebrity makes Hurts seem boring and lowers his perceived value.
Arch Manning's Hype Outpaces His Sample Size
- McIntyre and James Palmer caution that Arch Manning's reputation outpaces his limited college playing sample.
- They emphasize small sample risk and that hype may not equal proven readiness for elite competition.
Treat Arch's Season As A Long-Term Build
- Rachel Nichols and Jason McIntyre advise tempering expectations for Arch in prime-time games and treating his season as a long-term project.
- They recommend viewing his development across years rather than judging him solely on one marquee start.