Exploring the concept of equality in different societies throughout history, discussing various tribes and their beliefs and practices regarding equality. Also touches on the transition from hunter-gatherer communities to civilizations and the philosophical perspectives of John Locke, Hobbes, and Prudeon. It examines how the majority uses cultural tools to keep the powerful in check, the effects of status on conversations and the detrimental effects of inequality.
Hunter-gatherer societies exhibited a commitment to egalitarianism, with participatory decision making and an insistence on the equal rights of all members.
Alongside the capacity for domination, humans also possess a desire for rebellion, indicating a universal drive towards justice and fairness.
Deep dives
Egalitarianism in Hunter-Gatherer Societies
Before the rise of civilization, hunter-gatherer societies exhibited a resolute commitment to egalitarianism. Decision making was participatory, domination was intolerable, and freedom was highly valued. These egalitarian practices were observed in various hunter-gatherer tribes across continents, suggesting a universal inclination towards equality. Anthropologist Christopher Boem describes their approach as a 'reverse domination hierarchy,' where no single individual could dominate the entire community. Leaders were seen as first among equals, and arrogance or aggression was prohibited. Equality was not merely the absence of authority figures, but a positive insistence on the equal rights of all members of the community.
The Desire for Rebellion and the Potential for Domination
Humans possess a remarkable range of political capabilities, ranging from oppressive despotism to complex democracy to selfless egalitarianism. Alongside the capacity for domination, there is also an enduring desire for rebellion. This suggests that while domination is a natural tendency, our species also values freedom and equality. The presence of policing and the need for extraordinary efforts to maintain inequality in modern capitalist societies indicate discontent and a pursuit of status. However, the desire for rebellion also suggests an underlying universal drive towards justice and fairness.
Tools to Maintain Equality and Reinforce Egalitarianism
Throughout history, egalitarian societies have developed various cultural tools to keep the powerful in check. Ostracism, gossiping, and ridicule have been effective means to maintain equality. Communities utilize communal sanctions and shared values to prevent dominant individuals from consolidating power. Additionally, generosity and concern for the common will are highly valued leadership traits in many societies. By rotating leadership responsibilities, sharing surplus resources, and valuing self-control over self-aggrandizement, these communities prioritize equality over dominance. It seems that the impulse towards equality and the resistance against dominance is deeply ingrained in human nature.
Is Equality Natural? Do We Have a Natural Impulse Towards Equality? This is a philosophical tour of how philosophers have answered the equality question, and how hunter-gatherers, tribesman, and homo sapiens for 95% of their history, have been egalitarian. Based on Christopher Boehm's book, Heirarchy in the Forest: The Evolution of Egalitarian Behaviour, I look at the !Kung, The Semai, The Utku, Native North Americans and others to explore why they treated each other as equals. I also take a look at Hobbes, Locke, and Proudhon and the idea of natural rights.Then & Now is FAN-FUNDED! Support me on Patreon and pledge as little as $1 per video: http://patreon.com/user?u=3517018