Christians and Preferred Pronouns: Is it Biblical? (with Preston Sprinkle)
Mar 11, 2025
auto_awesome
In this enlightening conversation, Preston Sprinkle, a biblical scholar and head of the Center for Faith, Sexuality, and Gender, engages in a deep dive on the use of preferred pronouns within Christian faith. He discusses the evolving dialogue on LGBTQ issues in the church and emphasizes the importance of compassionate engagement amidst changing societal norms. The discussion touches on the complexities of gender identity, the balance between truth and love, and the implications for church communities navigating these contemporary challenges.
The church's engagement with LGBTQ issues has evolved significantly, reflecting a broader cultural shift towards inclusivity and dialogue within congregations.
The complexity of the LGBTQ movement is evident in shifting focuses from same-sex marriage to transgender rights, creating internal tensions among activists.
Debates around the use of preferred pronouns illustrate the delicate balance between maintaining relationships and upholding traditional theological beliefs on gender identity.
Deep dives
Shifts in the Church's LGBTQ Conversation
The conversation within the church regarding LGBTQ issues has evolved significantly over the past decade. Many churches that previously avoided discussions on sexuality are now actively engaging in dialogue, particularly in light of increasing LGBTQ representation within their congregations. The need for churches to address these topics is underscored by the growing number of individuals, especially Gen Z, who identify as LGBTQ. This shift indicates a more open and necessary engagement, though the quality and direction of these conversations can vary widely.
The Transformation of LGBTQ Activism Post-Obergefell
Since the Obergefell v. Hodges Supreme Court decision legalized same-sex marriage, the focus of LGBTQ activism has shifted towards transgender rights, particularly as visibility for trans individuals has increased significantly. This change has led to noticeable friction within the broader LGBTQ community, especially between older and newer activists, with tensions arising around issues such as gender identity. The emergence of groups advocating for the rights and concerns of lesbian women highlights the complexities and fractures within the LGBTQ movement. This division illustrates that the LGBTQ discourse is no longer monolithic; rather, it encompasses a spectrum of beliefs and ideologies.
Personal Journeys and Theological Stances
The discussion includes personal reflections on how individuals involved in LGBTQ dialogues have shifted their own theological understandings over time. As one speaker notes, earlier openness to alternative perspectives has evolved into a firmer stance on traditional marriage and the belief that deviations from this norm represent a significant departure from historical Christian orthodoxy. Despite this change, there remains a commitment to engage compassionately with LGBTQ individuals. This evolution emphasizes the need for clear, well-founded theological positions while maintaining a loving and welcoming approach.
The Complexity of Pronouns in LGBTQ Conversations
Pronouns remain a contentious issue within contemporary discussions on gender identity, raising questions about the intersection of language and belief. One perspective argues for the use of preferred pronouns as a means of maintaining relationships without affirming an ideology one fundamentally disagrees with, highlighting the flexibility and shared nature of language. Conversely, others caution that using gendered pronouns contrary to biological identity could normalize beliefs that conflict with traditional views of gender. This tension illustrates the need for discernment when navigating relationships with individuals who identify differently than their biological sex.
Cultural Impacts on Faith and Identity
The conversation acknowledges the broader cultural implications of LGBTQ activism, particularly concerning sports and women’s rights. The example of a biological male competing in female sports underscores the concerns surrounding fairness and the protection of women’s spaces. This scenario reflects a growing sentiment among many that affirming individual identities must not come at the expense of established gender norms and equal opportunities. Ultimately, the exchange emphasizes the importance of maintaining biblical principles while navigating complex societal shifts regarding gender identity.
Should Christians use preferred pronouns? Is it wise and biblically permissible, or not? While Sean has had this discussion before on the Think Biblically podcast, this episode features a conversation with Preston Sprinkle, and they go even deeper. They also discuss how the LGBTQ conversation has shifted in the church over the past decade.
Preston Sprinkle is Biblical scholar, speaker, and the head of the Center for Faith, Sexuality, and Gender. He is the best-selling author of multiple books including Embodied: Transgender Identities, the Church, and What the Bible Has to Say and Does the Bible Support Same-Sex Marriage? He hosts the popular podcast Theology in the Raw.
==========
Think Biblically: Conversations on Faith and Culture is a podcast from Talbot School of Theology at Biola University, which offers degrees both online and on campus in Southern California.
To submit comments, ask questions, or make suggestions on issues you'd like us to cover or guests you'd like us to have on the podcast, email us at thinkbiblically@biola.edu.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
