Bavarian Podcast Works S6E11: Is Thomas Tuchel still the right guy for Bayern Munich? + Can Julian Nagelsmann fix Germany?
Sep 25, 2023
auto_awesome
Thomas Tuchel, coach of Bayern Munich, and Julian Nagelsmann, newly hired Germany coach, are the guests on this podcast. Topics include Tuchel's performance and potential problems at Bayern Munich, the philosophical difference between hiring and firing coaches, Nagelsmann's capability to fix Germany, leadership issues in Germany, and upcoming matches for Bayern Munich.
The appointment of Julian Nagelsmann as the coach of the German national team is seen as a positive development, bringing new ideas and tactics to the team, but the success of his tenure will depend on the team's performance in the upcoming Euros.
There are concerns about the leadership and captaincy of the German national team, with doubts about whether Ilkay Gundogan possesses traditional leadership qualities and the potential confusion when Manuel Neuer returns, and the success of Germany under Nagelsmann relies on his ability to address these concerns and get the best out of the squad.
Deep dives
Nagelsmann takes over as Germany coach with short-term contract
Union Nagelsmann has been appointed as the new coach of the German national team, with a short-term contract that will last until the end of the Euro 2024. This move comes after the departure of Hans-Dieter Flick, and Bayern Munich had to pay a fee for Nagelsmann to join the national team. The appointment of Nagelsmann is seen as a positive development, as he is a proven tactician and can bring new ideas to the team. However, there are questions about whether Germany's current group of players are uncoachable, as they have struggled in recent years. The success of Nagelsmann's tenure will depend on the team's performance in the upcoming Euros, and if they fail to achieve a good result, there may be a need for a long-term review of Germany's youth strategy.
Leadership and Captaincy questions surround the German national team
There have been discussions about the leadership and captaincy of the German national team. Ilkay Gundogan has been appointed as the new captain, but there are doubts about whether he possesses the traditional leadership qualities. Some have questioned the decision to build the team around Gundogan, as it may cause confusion when Manuel Neuer returns. The success of Germany under Nagelsmann will depend on his ability to get the best out of the squad and address leadership concerns. If the team fails in the upcoming Euros, there may be a need for a long-term review of personnel and strategies.
The future of Germany under Nagelsmann and potential changes
The short-term appointment of Nagelsmann as the coach of the German national team raises questions about the team's future. It is expected that Nagelsmann will not stay beyond the Euro 2024, as he has ambitions of returning to club management. If Germany fails to achieve a good result in the Euros, there may be a need for new personnel and strategies. Some suggested changes include giving opportunities to young players like Florian Wirtz and Jamal Musiala and reviewing the roles of underperforming players. The performance of the team in the upcoming Euros will determine the future direction of German football.
Expectations for the upcoming match against Poßon Munster
The upcoming match against Poßon Munster offers an opportunity for Bayern Munich to give playing time to young talents like Katsuya and Musiala. These players have shown promise and deserve a chance to start. The match also allows for experimentation with different formations, such as three at the back. It is important for Bayern to secure a win in this match and provide valuable experience to the younger players. The focus should be on maintaining a positive momentum and building confidence within the squad.
So another week of football has gone by, and Bayern Munich have won two games in a row. In the meantime, Germany have hired Julian Nagelsmann (thanks to some financial help from the Bavarians) and we have reports that Matthijs de Ligt is unhappy with his situation (shock, horror!). Overall, a mixed week of events but the main subject of discussion are the two coaches — Tuchel and Nagelsmann.
In this episode, INNN and Marcus discuss the following:
What do we think of Thomas Tuchel at Bayern Munich so far?
How the games against Manchester United and Bayer Leverkusen speak against the current coach.
Is Tuchel causing problems in the dressing room?
Marcus makes an unconvincing defense of Tuchel so far.
The philosophical difference between hiring and firing coaches.
How important is the RB Leipzig game next week?
How can Tuchel improve the team going forward?
Is Julian Nagelsmann capable of fixing Germany?
What happens if he can’t do it?
What is the leadership issue at Germany? Is Gündoğan the right choice of captain?
What should Germany do if Nagelsmann can’t fix things?
A quick look at the Preußen Münster game in the DFB Pokal coming up.
Be sure to stay tuned to Bavarian Podcast Works for all of your up to date coverage on Bayern Munich and Germany. Follow us on Twitter @BavarianFBWorks, @TheBarrelBlog, @tommyadams71, @bfwinnn, and more.
