Matthew Taylor, Chief executive of the NHS Confederation, discusses healthcare and assisted dying. Ash Sarkar, a contributor to Novara Media, dives into the social implications of mortality. Anne McElvoy from Politico offers a political lens on death, while Charlotte Haigh shares personal insights as a funeral director. Anton Noble explores young people's views on violence and death. Teodora Manea provides philosophical reflections, emphasizing the importance of confronting mortality for a richer understanding of life. Insights span from the historical context of death to its modern societal impacts.
Modern society's detachment from death raises ethical questions about our attitudes toward mortality and assisted dying.
Cultural variances influence how individuals perceive death, shifting focus from communal mourning to individual experiences and potential isolation.
Philosophical perspectives advocate for embracing mortality as a means to lead more fulfilling lives and foster deeper connections.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Mortality Awareness
Awareness of mortality shapes human life uniquely, creating a complex relationship with death. People tend to react differently to the knowledge of their inevitable demise, treating it with fear, fascination, or acceptance. Unlike previous generations, who were intimately familiar with death due to high childhood mortality rates, modern society is somewhat detached from it. This separation raises ethical questions regarding the attitude towards death and assisted dying, prompting reflection on whether to fear or accept this natural part of existence.
Perspectives on Assisted Dying
The topic of assisted dying evokes varied opinions, highlighting the nuances of personal views on death. Some individuals, like Matthew Taylor, support assisted dying but express concern surrounding the implications it may carry for individuals with disabilities. Others, including Konstantin Kissin, recognize the need for caution, warning against potential abuses observed in other countries, while others like Ash Sarkar acknowledge the painful experiences of dying individuals, advocating for personal agency in choosing how to die. These conversations reflect deep-seated emotions surrounding mortality and the control individuals desire over their end-of-life experiences.
Societal Attitudes Towards Death
Current societal attitudes toward death lean toward avoidance, with many embracing euphemisms to soften the topic. Experts like Charlotte Hague note a trend toward openness among progressive funeral directors and authors discussing death candidly. Although there exist positive shifts in the conversation about dying, the overall cultural discomfort remains potent, often steering discussions toward abstraction rather than real engagement. By fostering a familiarity with death, society may reduce fear, allowing for healthier discussions and support systems when facing bereavement.
Cultural and Psychological Influences
Cultural variances significantly shape how individuals perceive death, with some societies celebrating it through rituals while others shy away. Historical comparisons reveal that the Victorians, accustomed to regular encounters with death, developed more pragmatic and communal approaches to loss than contemporary society, where individualism prevails. This evolution in cultural attitudes shifts focus from collective mourning to individual experiences, which can lead to increased anxiety and isolation. Understanding these differences underscores the importance of open conversations about death that can contribute to a healthier societal response.
Philosophical Reflections on Death
Philosophical perspectives on death emphasize its role in shaping a meaningful life, urging society to embrace mortality rather than fear it. Existential philosophy posits that acknowledging death should prompt individuals to lead more fulfilling lives, encouraging deeper connections and personal growth. Discussions surrounding the autonomy of individuals in deciding when and how to die intersect with considerations about community impact, highlighting the intricate balance between personal choice and societal values. Engaging with philosophical ideas offers a pathway to confront mortality thoughtfully and constructively, fostering a culture that neither demonizes nor idealizes death.
The debate around assisted dying exposes fundamental questions about our attitudes to death. We will all die. Nothing is more certain. But it’s not something most of us really think about, apart from superficially. We can often think of death as something that happens to other people. There’s a paradox – we are more distanced from death than our ancestors, yet we are exposed to it every day in the news and value it as a key component of art and entertainment. We can have a morbid fascination with death but a fear of confronting our own mortality.
While, fear, anxiety and avoidance are deeply human responses, are they good for us both psychologically and morally? Those advocating a “death positive” approach see honest conversations about death and dying as the cornerstone of a healthy society. In theory, thinking about your death should put your life into perspective and direct your actions towards things that are good for you and others. But is that necessarily the case? Should death ever be seen as anything less than a tragedy? During the pandemic, there were concerns about the subtle messaging around the ‘acceptability’ of some deaths over others. In conflict, repeated exposure to death causes a callus to form, where there may be less empathy for the dead as a survival mechanism for the living.
Does a greater openness and acceptance of death help us to live better lives? Or can losing the fear of death mean we lose something of what it means to be human? What is a healthy attitude to death?
Chair: Michael Buerk
Panel: Matthew Taylor, Ash Sarkar, Konstantin Kisin and Anne McElvoy
Witnesses: Charlotte Haigh, Anton Noble, Victoria Holmes, Teodora Manea.
Producer: Dan Tierney
Assistant producer: Ruth Purser
Editor: Gill Farrington and Chloe Walker.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode