Jennifer D. Ortegren, "Middle-Class Dharma: Gender, Aspiration, and the Making of Contemporary Hinduism" (Oxford UP, 2023)
Sep 21, 2023
auto_awesome
Jennifer D. Ortegren, ethnographer of class mobility among Hindus in Udaipur, Rajasthan, discusses the role of gender and aspiration in shaping contemporary Hinduism. The podcast explores women's experiences in becoming middle-class, negotiating dharma in consumer practices, and reimagining Hindu traditions. It also delves into the influence of caste on class mobility and the impact of women in transmitting culture. Overall, the podcast provides an insightful exploration of the complex intersection of gender, class, and religion in contemporary Indian society.
Middle-class dharma in contemporary Hinduism is not just a socioeconomic process, but also a religious one.
Hindu women strategically align emerging middle-class desires with traditional religious obligations to shape new dharmic boundaries.
Deep dives
Women's Role in Shaping Middle-Class Dharma
The podcast episode explores how women in contemporary Hinduism play a critical role in shaping middle-class dharma. The speaker discusses the flexibility that exists within Hinduism, particularly for women, and the possibilities for power and agency that come with it. The research is based on the experiences of Hindu women who have moved from the village to the city, and it examines the changes in their lives and religious practices as they become middle-class. The argument is made that class itself can be seen as a religious identity, and becoming middle-class is a religious process.
Dharma as a Resonant Concept
The concept of dharma is explored in this episode, emphasizing its multi-valent nature. Dharma is described as a moral identity that holds the world together, both at the cosmic and everyday levels. The speaker highlights the ways in which mundane practices, such as food and clothing choices, are imbued with ontological resonance. The use of dharma as an analytical tool is discussed, allowing for a broader understanding of what constitutes religion, beyond mere belief. It is also mentioned that dharma can be used as a pedagogical concept to help students analyze and appreciate the significance of everyday practices.
The Relationship Between Caste and Class
The podcast touches upon the complex relationship between caste and class in contemporary India. While there is an increasing discourse that caste does not matter among the middle classes, the speaker acknowledges that caste continues to play a relevant role, albeit often in more covert ways. The research focuses on lower caste communities who strive for upward mobility but face limitations in breaking through due to factors such as lack of English language proficiency and restricted access to networks. The interplay between caste and class, and the impact on mobility, is explored.
Research Process and Surprising Findings
The speaker shares insights into their research process, which involved spending time in a neighborhood where they lived and interacting with the women there. The research approach blended informal interviews and observational participation in everyday activities, such as cooking and conversations in women's kitchens. The speaker expresses admiration for the women's resilience and the community they built as they pursued middle-class aspirations. The episode concludes with a mention of future research, which will explore similar questions within Muslim communities and the reshaping of women's relationships as they experience upward mobility.
Middle-Class Dharma: Gender, Aspiration, and the Making of Contemporary Hinduism(Oxford UP, 2023) is a contemporary ethnography of class mobility among Hindus in Udaipur, Rajasthan, India. Focusing on women in Pulan, an emerging middle-class neighborhood of Udaipur, Jennifer D. Ortegren argues that upward class mobility is not just a socio-economic process, but also a religious one.
Central to Hindu women's upward class mobility is negotiating dharma, the moral and ethical groundings of Hindu worlds. As women experiment with middle-class consumer and lifestyle practices, they navigate tensions around what is possible and what is appropriate--that is, what is dharmic--as middle-class Hindu women. Ortegren shows how these women strategically align emerging middle-class desires with more traditional religious obligations in ways that enable them to generate new dharmic boundaries and religious selfhoods in the middle classes. Such transitions can be as joyful as they are difficult and disorienting.
Middle-Class Dharma explores how contemporary Hindu women's everyday practices reimagine and reshape Hindu traditions. By developing dharma as an analytical category and class as a dharmic category, Ortegren pushes for expanding definitions of religion in academia, both within and beyond the study of Hinduism in South Asia.
Raj Balkaran is a scholar of Sanskrit narrative texts. He teaches at the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies and at his own virtual School of Indian Wisdom. For information see rajbalkaran.com.