The Message by Ta-Nehisi Coates and What Writing is For with Jazmine Hughes
Oct 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Jazmine Hughes, a talented writer, joins Ta-Nehisi Coates, a renowned author and commentator on minority experiences, for a captivating discussion. They delve into Coates' latest book, exploring the writer-as-activist concept and how minority writers navigate media relationships. The conversation touches on identity, the responsibilities of journalism, and the challenges of balancing personal narratives with broader societal issues. They also reflect on the evolving dynamics in journalism, particularly at prestigious outlets like the New York Times.
The podcast discusses Ta-Nehisi Coates' exploration of the moral responsibilities of writers in shaping societal narratives through his book, The Message.
Jazmine Hughes shares her experiences navigating institutional pressures at the New York Times Magazine while advocating for critical social justice issues like race and conflict.
The complexities of identity for Black writers are examined, emphasizing their role in connecting domestic and global struggles for human rights and justice.
Deep dives
Discussion on Ta-Nehisi Coates’ New Book, The Message
The conversation revolves around Ta-Nehisi Coates' book, The Message, which comprises four essays addressing significant themes, particularly the responsibilities of writers in the media. Coates’ first essay revisits George Orwell’s Why I Write, where he advises his students on the political considerations inherent in their writing. The last essay offers reflections on a trip to the West Bank, leading him to reconsider previously held views on reparations and the intersection of race and identity. This sequence of essays aims to provoke thought on how media and journalism can influence societal narratives and the moral responsibilities those in these fields carry.
Reflections on Personal Experiences within Journalism
Jasmine Hughes shares her personal experiences at the New York Times Magazine, discussing the transformative period surrounding the 1619 Project and the contrasting reactions from the institution when it comes to topics such as race and the recent Gaza conflict. After signing open letters condemning media stances on these issues, Hughes faced repercussions, leading to her dismissal despite her previous accolades. This highlights the dilemma faced by journalists, especially people of color, in navigating institutional pressures while advocating for crucial social issues. The complexity of activism in journalism emerges as a critical topic for writers contributing to the discourse on media obligations.
The Shift in Media’s Response to Social Justice
The podcast touches on the evolving media landscape and how reactions to social justice issues have changed over time, especially in light of the Black Lives Matter movement and ongoing conflicts in Palestine. Hughes and her colleagues noticed a stark difference in the media’s response to racial injustices in America compared to international conflicts involving marginalized communities, suggesting an inconsistency in institutional support for writers addressing these matters. The discussion also raises questions about the expectations and limitations placed on journalists, especially those from underrepresented backgrounds, to engage with activism while fulfilling traditional reporting roles. This highlights a tension between personal convictions and professional responsibilities amidst an evolving media environment.
Exploring Identity and Solidarity
The conversation delves into the implications of identity for Black writers in response to global issues, particularly the alignment of historical struggles faced by Black Americans with those experienced by Palestinians. Coates’ reflections on his travels expose a broader narrative of oppression that transcends geographical boundaries, prompting introspection about collective responsibility and solidarity. The panelists discuss the complexities of being perceived as advocates or representatives solely based on racial identity, emphasizing the personal choice to engage with these discourses rather than a mandated obligation. This leads to a nuanced understanding of how individual experiences with systemic oppression can inform perspectives on international human rights issues.
The Role of Celebrity in Journalism
The role of celebrity in shaping narratives within journalism is examined, particularly how Coates' stature impact perceptions of his writing and advocacy for the Palestinian cause. The authors note the expectations placed on prominent figures to address pressing global issues, raising concerns about the responsibility that comes with celebrity status. Furthermore, the conversation critiques the tendency for media discussions to center around the celebrity rather than the actual issues at hand, diluting the urgency of the topics being addressed. This complex relationship between personal fame, public discourse, and activism highlights ongoing challenges in maintaining focus on critical matters while navigating the fame associated with influential writers.
Apologies for the slight delay in getting this episode out but we have a great show today with the writer Jazmine Hughes. We talk about Ta-Nehisi Coates’s new book about writing, the West Bank and his travels, the writer-as-activist-celebrity, and the strange and tangled relationship that we, as minority writers, have with prestige media outlets.
Enjoy!
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit goodbye.substack.com/subscribe
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
