This week, energy expert John Kemp, owner of Base Research, joins the conversation to dissect the recent 18-hour blackout in the Iberian Peninsula. He dives into the fragility of power grids and the critical role of renewable energy. The hosts also challenge the relevance of GDP as an economic measure, calling for a broader perspective on well-being and inequality. Finally, they explore the pitfalls of stack ranking management in the tech world, arguing for more collaborative workplace cultures.
The recent blackout in the Iberian Peninsula highlighted the vulnerabilities of power grids and the challenges posed by increasing reliance on renewable energy sources.
Critics argue that negative GDP figures do not adequately represent the broader economic health or quality of life, necessitating alternative metrics for evaluation.
The resurgence of stack ranking in workplaces raises concerns about its negative impact on culture and employee collaboration, suggesting a need for better management practices.
Deep dives
The Iberian Power Grid Blackout
A significant blackout in the Iberian Peninsula affected both Spain and Portugal, revealing the inherent fragility of their electrical grids. This incident brought to light the complexities of managing the power supply, as the blackout resulted from a cascade of failures triggered by an imbalance in electricity generation. Observers noted that while solar energy contributed significantly to the energy mix on the day of the blackout, it lacked the necessary inertia for grid stability. The failure of multiple layers of protection within the grid raises critical questions about how to prevent similar incidents in the future.
Importance of Inertia in Power Grids
Inertia is crucial for maintaining stability in power grids, as it allows traditional generation units like coal, gas, and nuclear power plants to respond to fluctuations in electricity demand. These large generating units store kinetic energy, providing a buffer against sudden changes in supply and demand. However, renewable energy sources such as solar and wind lack this inertia, leading to challenges in grid management as their share of total generation increases. This situation prompts utilities to reconsider how they integrate renewables without sacrificing grid reliability.
GDP Measurement and Its Implications
The recent negative GDP figure for the first quarter of the year sparked discussions about its relevance as an economic indicator. Critics argue that GDP fails to capture essential factors affecting quality of life and economic health, as it does not account for unpaid labor, healthcare quality, or inequality. The measurement's limitations may obscure a more nuanced understanding of the economy, especially when considering that negative GDP could arise from unusual circumstances such as pre-importing goods before tariff implementation. Experts emphasize the need for alternative metrics that reflect societal well-being rather than merely economic activity.
The Return of Stack Ranking in Corporate Performance Reviews
Stack ranking, a controversial performance evaluation system that ranks employees and typically leads to the dismissal of the lowest performers, is making a comeback in some major companies. This approach, originally popularized by GE's Jack Welch, has been criticized for fostering a competitive and distrustful workplace culture. In contrast, better management practices advocate for collaboration and an environment where employees can thrive collectively. Critics suggest that rather than focusing on high-stakes rankings, employers should prioritize effective communication and management to enhance team performance.
The Challenges of Performance Metrics in Large Organizations
As organizations grow, measuring employee performance becomes increasingly complex, often resulting in reliance on flawed metrics. While sales and engineering roles may have clear performance indicators, other positions lack straightforward measures of success. This can lead companies to adopt metrics like time in the office, which may not accurately reflect contribution or productivity. A shift towards assessing corporate culture and employee engagement is recommended to foster a more beneficial environment for overall company performance.
This week: The entire Iberian peninsula lost power for 18 hours. Felix Salmon, Emily Peck, and Elizabeth Spiers are joined by energy expert John Kemp to talk about why that might have happened and nerd out on power grids. Then, the GDP is down by 0.3%. But is that really the right metric to care about? Finally, the tech world is bringing back the brutal system of stack ranking management. The hosts discuss why this might be ill advised.
In the Slate Plus episode: Are Toy Tariffs…Good?
Want to hear that discussion and hear more Slate Money? Join Slate Plus to unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the Slate Money show page onApple Podcasts andSpotify. Or, visitslate.com/moneyplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Jessamine Molli and Cheyna Roth.
