Explore Hegel's intriguing concept of the 'beautiful soul' and its relevance to today's political landscape. The hosts dissect the tension between morality and political action, arguing for a shift towards embracing moral imperfection. Delve into the morality of forgiveness in politics, where sometimes lies might serve a greater good. They tackle right-wing populism and leftist dissatisfaction, seeking deeper truths beyond mere factuality. Finally, cinematic analyses of 'Wings of Desire' and 'Manhunter' reveal profound insights into love and identity.
Hegel's concept of the beautiful soul reveals the tension between ethical purity and the necessity of engaging in political action to drive change.
The critique of the beautiful soul highlights how contemporary social media activism often results in virtue signaling rather than addressing systemic issues.
Meaningful political engagement requires embracing imperfection and crafting a compelling narrative that resonates with people's identities and desires.
Deep dives
Understanding the Beautiful Soul
The concept of the 'beautiful soul' comes from Hegel and represents a developed stage of consciousness. This figure is characterized by a strong belief in ethical action but is paralyzed by a desire to maintain purity and correctness, ultimately leading to inaction. This position highlights a critique of the beautiful soul that, despite its moral stance, fails to enact real change or engage in the world, allowing undesirable conditions to persist. The discussion emphasizes that non-action becomes an act in itself, perpetuating the status quo and highlighting a significant philosophical concern regarding the implications of ethical purity.
Political Implications of the Beautiful Soul
The podcast explores how the beautiful soul manifests in contemporary politics, particularly regarding social media activism and consumer choices. Currently, individuals often perceive themselves as morally superior by avoiding certain brands instead of confronting larger structural issues. This aligns with Hegel's critique that mere acknowledgment of moral dilemmas without decisive action ultimately leads to conservative stagnation. The episode argues that such positions reflect a misguided belief in moral purity that neglects the necessary engagement with reality to drive genuine change.
The Distortion of Ethical Actions
Examples from social media illustrate how individuals express their moral beliefs by boycotting companies based on superficial compliance with ethical standards. The discussion highlights how this behavior can serve as a form of virtue signaling rather than fostering substantive political engagement. By focusing on individual consumer actions, larger systemic issues remain unaddressed, perpetuating the cycles of power and exploitation. This critique aligns with Hegel's assertion that the beautiful soul's lamentation over moral decay does not result in transformative political action.
The Notion of Getting Your Hands Dirty
The conversation emphasizes the necessity of embracing imperfection and the willingness to engage with messy realities to achieve meaningful political ends. The episode compares the protagonist's journey in Michael Mann's 'Manhunter' with that of the beautiful soul, underscoring the idea that genuine action often requires compromising one's sense of purity. In 'Manhunter', the protagonist's transformation from an unwilling participant to one who dives into the depths of human darkness is essential for solving crimes and confronting evil. This shift illustrates the philosophical assertion that real change requires embracing one's own moral complexity.
Political Engagement Beyond Moral Purity
The podcast argues that political action must transcend mere criticism of the status quo, focusing instead on creating a positive vision for the future. It suggests that the contemporary political landscape suffers from an overemphasis on factual accuracy at the expense of a compelling narrative that resonates with people's desires and identities. By reorienting away from just opposing right-wing populism and articulating a positive program, leftist politics can regain its effectiveness. Ultimately, embracing the idea of being beautifully soiled serves as a framework for engaging in a more authentic and impactful political discourse.
Ryan and Todd explore Hegel’s concept of the beautiful soul as he lays it out in the Phenomenology of Spirit. They discuss the contemporary political situation in terms of this figure and theorize about its predominance in today’s landscape. The beautiful soul also becomes a way of thinking through the difference between Kant and Hegel or between morality and politics.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode