Edward Tenner, an independent writer and Distinguished Scholar at the Smithsonian, brings fascinating insights into technology and its unintended consequences. He discusses how lifeboats, introduced after the Titanic disaster, inadvertently led to another tragedy. Tenner explores the role of wild animals as investors and the historical significance of the tab as a visual metaphor. He also highlights Amish artisans' impact on technology and reflects on the effects of AI on creativity, urging a cautious approach to its integration in academia.
01:01:20
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Why the Hindenburg Had a Smoking Lounge Despite the Fire Risk
Edward Tenner reveals a fascinating paradox behind the Hindenburg's smoking lounge: despite the obvious fire dangers of a hydrogen airship, the smoking lounge existed to meet passenger expectations.
Since tickets were extremely expensive and half the passengers smoked, a no-smoking policy would have made the airship commercially unviable. Therefore, the company created a smoking lounge with strict fire prevention measures, including negative air pressure and coil lighters.
The critical weakness was human oversight—the steward had to ensure no lit smoke escaped the lounge, a risky responsibility during social distractions. This situation exemplifies Tenner's concept of a "community of expectations," where social norms and economic pressures influence technical and safety decisions.
This insight illustrates how unintended consequences often stem from balancing technical risks with human behavior and market demands, a theme repeated in other transportation disasters like the Titanic.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Hindenburg's Smoking Lounge Paradox
The Hindenburg had a smoking lounge because half its wealthy passengers smoked and forbidding smoking would have hurt ticket sales.
The lounge had safety measures, but relied on stewards to prevent fire risks, showing human factors in technical safety.
insights INSIGHT
People Cause Tech Disasters
People issues often cause technical disasters more than engineering failures.
Machines are designed and programmed by people whose values and expectations influence outcomes.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Richard Feynman's 'QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter' offers a clear and accessible explanation of quantum electrodynamics (QED), the theory describing how light and matter interact. Feynman uses simple language and thought experiments to demystify the complex concepts of quantum mechanics for a general audience. He explores phenomena such as reflection, refraction, and the behavior of subatomic particles, revealing the counterintuitive nature of the quantum world. The book presents QED as the most accurate theory in physics, despite its strangeness, emphasizing its experimental verification and predictive power. Feynman's engaging style and insightful explanations make QED a compelling introduction to the fundamental principles of modern physics.
Artificial experts
H. M. Collins
Why the Hindenburg Had a Smoking Lounge
Why the Hindenburg Had a Smoking Lounge
Edward Tenner
Why things bite back
Edward Tenner
Plays and Peoples
Plays and Peoples
William H. Mcneill
How did the addition of lifeboats after the Titanic shipwreck contribute to another tragedy in Chicago harbor three years later? How efficient are wild animals as investors, and how do dog breeds become national symbols? Why have scientific breakthroughs so often originated in the study of shadows? How did the file card prepare scholarship and commerce for the rise of electronic data processing, and why did the visual metaphor of the tab survive into today's graphic interfaces? Why have Amish artisans played an important role in manufacturing advanced technology? Why was United Shoe Machinery the Microsoft of the 1890s? Surprises like these, Edward Tenner believes, can help us deal with the technological issues that confront us now.
Since the 1980s, Edward Tenner has contributed essays on technology, design, and culture to leading magazines, newspapers, and professional journals, and has been interviewed on subjects ranging from medical ethics to typography. Why the Hindenburg Had a Smoking Lounge: Essays in Unintended Consequences(American Philosophical Society Press, 2025)--named for one of the paradoxes that can result from the inherent contradictions between consumer safety and product marketing--brings many of Tenner's essays together into one volume for the first time, accompanied by new introductions by the author on the theme of each work. As an independent historian and public speaker, Tenner has spent his career deploying concepts from economics, engineering, psychology, science, and sociology, to explore both the negative and positive surprises of human ingenuity.
Edward Tenner is an independent writer and Distinguished Scholar in the Smithsonian's Lemelson Center for the Study of Invention and Innovation. He was a visiting scholar at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton and teaches the course Understanding Disasters at Princeton University.
New Books in Sociology 
