Consider This from NPR What makes a holiday song a lasting hit?
5 snips
Dec 24, 2024 Stephen Thompson, NPR Music journalist and expert in music analysis, dives into the enchanting world of holiday songs. He discusses why Mariah Carey's 'All I Want for Christmas Is You' has maintained its reign for three decades. The conversation touches on the emotional depth that makes holiday music resonate, noting that true charm often lies in melancholy rather than cheer. Thompson also highlights contemporary artists like Kelly Clarkson and Sabrina Carpenter for their fresh takes on holiday melodies, encouraging listeners to explore a diverse array of festive tunes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Timeless Appeal
- Mariah Carey's "All I Want for Christmas Is You" combines timelessness and nostalgia, reminiscent of girl groups.
- Its impeccable production, especially the opening vocals, contributes to its appeal, despite being overplayed.
Ingredients of Holiday Music
- Stephen Thompson prioritizes sincerity and a touch of melancholy in good holiday music.
- He dislikes music that pressures listeners to be happy, preferring sadness to forced cheer.
Modern Holiday Classic
- Thompson recommends "All That I Want" by The Weepies, highlighting its classic holiday elements and genuine warmth.
- Deb Talan's vocals and the song's comforting message about love and family stand out.