Tim Robey, a seasoned film critic at The Telegraph and author of 'Box Office Poison: Hollywood's Story in a Century of Flops,' dives into the intriguing world of Hollywood failures. He reveals how flops have historically influenced the industry's business models and examines notable disasters like 'Gigli.' Robey discusses the shift towards established franchises to mitigate financial risks and reflects on the potential impacts of superhero fatigue on future projects. His insights shed light on the lessons learned from cinematic missteps.
Hollywood flops historically forced studios to adapt their business strategies, highlighting the financial risks linked to film production and marketing.
The shift towards established intellectual properties in filmmaking demonstrates both a risk-averse approach and the industry's struggle with audience unpredictability.
Deep dives
Understanding Hollywood Flops
A flop in Hollywood is defined primarily as a film that fails to recoup a significant portion of its production budget. For instance, if 'Gladiator 2' were to gross less than $300 million worldwide, it would be considered a substantial failure, given that this amount does not account for marketing and distribution costs. This exploration into Hollywood failures allows for a chronological understanding of how the industry has evolved in terms of budget management, production expectations, and audience engagement. By analyzing the historical flops, lessons emerge about the common pitfalls that continue to affect filmmakers and studios today.
The Impact of Box Office Awareness
Public awareness of box office performance began to rise notably in the 1970s and 1980s, coinciding with the success of blockbuster films. The coverage of both hit and flop movies became almost competitive, turning box office performances into a topic of public interest akin to sports statistics. Major failures like 'Heaven's Gate' showcased the financial repercussions of underperforming films, leading to significant studio bankruptcies and shifts in production strategies. As audiences grew more conscious of a film's financial success or failure, it stressed the importance of effective marketing and the pressures faced by filmmakers to produce commercially viable content.
Evolving Business Models in Hollywood
In the wake of significant flops like 'Gigli', Hollywood underwent a transformation in its business models, leading to a focus on established intellectual properties (IP) rather than star-driven projects. The success of franchises like the Marvel Cinematic Universe demonstrated a more sustainable, risk-averse approach where studios prioritize familiar characters over new concepts, significantly reducing the chances of failure. However, recent missteps, such as the disappointing reception of sequels from established franchises, indicate that even this model is susceptible to the unpredictability of audience preferences. The industry's cyclical nature reflects an ongoing challenge to balance innovation with the financial imperatives inherent in filmmaking.
When most people think of the movies, they think of Oscar-winning classics and popular summer blockbusters. But Hollywood's failures — its flops — are often more significant. Over the years, flops have bankrupted studios and forced Hollywood to modify its business model — and recent superhero flops may cause yet another evolution. Tim Robey, a longtime film critic at The Telegraph and the author of Box Office Poison: Hollywood's Story in a Century of Flops, joins to discuss the business of movie failures.
Join our host Mark Dent, for an in-depth conversation with Tim Robey.
Thank You For Listening to The Hustle Daily Show. Don’t forget to hit Subscribe or Follow us on Apple Podcasts so you never miss an episode! If you want this news delivered to your inbox, join millions of others and sign up for The Hustle Daily newsletter, here: https://thehustle.co/email/