Henry Grabar, a staff writer at Slate, digs into the surprising rise of Donald Trump in traditionally Democratic cities, alongside New York State Representative Ron Kim, who has a deep understanding of his diverse district. They explore how dissatisfaction with Democratic leadership and economic pressures, like rising costs, are reshaping voting patterns. The duo also discusses the complexities of voter support for Trump amidst calls for progressive change, revealing the challenges progressives face in connecting with their constituents.
The significant shift of urban voters towards the Republican Party reflects their dissatisfaction with Democratic responses to public safety and living costs.
Growing support for Republican candidates among Latino and Asian American communities indicates a transformative realignment in urban political affiliations driven by economic concerns.
Deep dives
Urban Democratic Shifts and Voter Discontent
A notable trend is the increasing shift of voters in major cities towards the Republican Party, which poses significant challenges for the Democratic coalition. This change is evident in cities like New York and Miami, where traditional Democratic strongholds displayed substantial movement towards Trump, with statistics indicating Trump came within five points of winning New Jersey and garnered significant support in New York City. One major factor appears to be the discontent among voters regarding the handling of public safety and rise in living costs, especially within communities of color. As urban voters reassess their loyalties, understanding this shift is crucial for the Democratic Party to maintain its relevance in urban political landscapes.
Shift in Minority Voter Allegiance
An essential insight revolves around the increasing support for Republican candidates from minority groups, particularly within Latino and Asian American communities. These demographic changes suggest a potential realignment in political preferences influenced by economic concerns, such as rising grocery prices, which are paramount for many voters. It was noted that voters in diverse districts, despite being registered Democrats, expressed conservative views and supported Trump due to dissatisfaction with the Democratic response to their immediate needs. This shift indicates a more complex voter landscape, where traditional alliances may no longer hold as urban constituents seek representation that directly addresses their pressing issues.
The Impact of Media Fragmentation on Voting Behavior
The fragmentation of media and information sources appears to have contributed to the rightward shift seen in urban areas, influencing how voters perceive local governance and party messaging. As voters increasingly consume news through platforms like TikTok, they may be exposed to conservative ideologies and disinformation, complicating their understanding of political issues. This phenomenon suggests a decline in local media’s influence, as regional narratives are overshadowed by broader, often polarized national narratives. The shift underscores the importance of reevaluating how political entities engage voters through modern communication channels to ensure they meet the needs of their constituencies.
Donald Trump retook the presidency, in part, by doing much better in American cities in 2024 than ever before. Why did these urban Democratic strongholds shift towards Republicans, and are these changes permanent?
Ron Kim, representative for New York State’s 40th Assembly District.
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
We want to hear from you! Submit your answers to our What Next listener survey at slate.com/WhatNextSurvey.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.
