A panel of football writers reflect on Neymar's move to Saudi Arabia and discuss his PSG legacy. They explore the changing perception of Neymar in Brazil and his frustration with Mbappe's emergence. The speakers delve into the conflicting expectations of Neymar as a football player and discuss his talent versus his controversial actions.
Neymar's time at PSG was plagued by injuries, inconsistent performances, and unfulfilled expectations, leading to a divided legacy.
Neymar's departure from PSG represents a loss in marketing appeal but also signifies the club's desire to redefine its image and adapt to changing global influences.
Deep dives
Neymar's Career at PSG and His Move to Saudi Pro League
Neymar's six-year journey at Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) is analyzed, highlighting the divided opinions on his achievements. While Neymar's signing was meant to elevate PSG and win major titles, his time at the club was marred by injuries and inconsistent performances in crucial moments. The recent move to the Saudi Pro League at the age of 31 has raised questions about his career choices and dedication as a player. Despite his undeniable talent and impact at PSG, Neymar's legacy is divided between what he accomplished for the club and what he could have achieved as a player.
Mixed Reactions to Neymar Leaving PSG
The departure of Neymar from PSG has garnered mixed reactions in Paris. While some acknowledge his contributions to the club, there is a sense that he fell short of the expectations set for him. Neymar was signed with the aim of winning the Champions League and stepping out of Lionel Messi's shadow, but neither of these objectives were fully realized. The disappointment lies in the missed opportunities and the perception that Neymar's professionalism and commitment were not always up to par. Despite this, there are still positive memories of his early performances at PSG, which are cherished by younger fans.
Neymar's Move to Saudi Arabia and Its Impact on PSG
Neymar's transfer to the Saudi Pro League has raised questions about the financial implications for PSG and the club's marketing strategy. PSG has successfully marketed itself as a global brand with Neymar playing a central role in boosting its visibility and commercial success. His departure represents a loss in terms of marketing appeal, but also signifies PSG's shift away from the 'Galactico' era and their desire to redefine their image. The move to Saudi Arabia also highlights the changing geopolitical influences in football and the global attraction of players like Neymar.
Perceptions of Neymar in Brazil
Neymar's career choices and performances have divided opinions in Brazil. While there were high expectations for him to become one of the best players in the world, there is a sense of unfulfilled potential. Brazilian fans recognize Neymar's technical skills and consider him one of the greatest dribblers of all time. However, criticisms arise from perceptions of his lack of dedication, professionalism, and focus. Many in Brazil question his decisions, such as moving to PSG and now the Saudi Pro League. Despite divided opinions, Neymar still holds a significant presence in Brazil and continues to attract attention and followers.
Ayo Akinwolere is joined by The Athletic's Peter Rutzler and Carl Anka, French football writer Tom Williams and Brazilian football correspondent Renato Senise, to reflect on Neymar's move to Saudi Arabia...
The panel assess his PSG legacy, after six years in the French capital and the world-record transfer fee, that represented a watershed moment for the sport.
Plus, how he is viewed back in Brazil and if Neymar remains a truly generational talent or a case of talent unfulfilled?
Produced by Adonis Pratsides
Additional Production: Mike Stavrou & Jay Beale
Executive Producer: Adey Moorhead
***
This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/athleticfootball and get on your way to being your best self.