Advisory Opinions The $2 Billion Dollar Case
21 snips
Mar 6, 2025 David Stras, appeals judge for the 8th Circuit, shares his insights on Supreme Court dynamics with Sarah Isgur and David French. They delve into the decline in cases reviewed by the Court and the implications of recent rulings, including a denial of Trump’s request. Stras discusses the role of bias response teams in universities and reflects on the impact of his grandparents' Holocaust experiences on his views of free speech. The conversation highlights the evolving landscape of judicial decision-making and the importance of clarity in legal opinions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Grandparents' Influence on Free Speech
- David Stras' grandparents were Holocaust survivors, shaping his view of free speech.
- His grandfather, despite having multiple sclerosis, spoke openly about his experiences, demonstrating the importance of speaking out, even when difficult.
Declining Supreme Court Caseload
- The Supreme Court's declining caseload is due to several factors, including the “cert pool” and justices seeking “perfect vehicles.”
- This has led to fewer cases being heard, impacting lower courts.
Perfect Vehicles vs. More Cases
- While the Supreme Court's focus on ideal cases leads to well-reasoned opinions, it also leaves circuit splits unresolved.
- This can create confusion for lower courts, highlighting a potential downside of prioritizing perfect vehicles.