Lucy Letby, a neo-natal nurse, is accused of attacking and murdering premature twin Baby E. The episode discusses the details of the attack, including text messages exchanged by Letby, and features an interview with the baby's mother. The podcast also explores the significance of court reporting in the modern era.
Lucy Letby allegedly attacked a premature baby with a medical tube, causing bleeding and ultimately his death.
The podcast highlights the importance of court reporting in bringing trial details to the public and preserving the tradition.
Deep dives
Baby E: Alleged Attack and Medical Treatment
Baby E was a premature baby who was allegedly attacked by Lucy Letby, a neonatal nurse. According to the prosecution's expert witness, Dr. Dowie Evans, Letby injured Baby E by forcefully inserting a medical tube down his throat, causing him to suffer bleeding in his upper gastrointestinal tract. It is alleged that it was an injection of air into his bloodstream that actually caused his death. Dr. David Harkness, the registrar on duty, testified that after the alleged attack, Baby E started vomiting blood and experienced a significant gastrointestinal bleed. The medical team attempted to stabilize him, administering fluids and preparing to ventilate him. Despite their efforts, Baby E's condition continued to deteriorate, and he eventually passed away.
Apologies and Contrasting Claims
The consultant who was initially in charge of Baby E's case initially believed that the baby's death was due to a bowel condition called necrotizing enterocolitis. However, after examining blood tests and x-rays, she changed her opinion and now believes that the bleeding was not caused by the bowel condition. The prosecution asserts that Baby E was attacked by Lucy Letby and injected with air into his bloodstream, leading to his death. Letby denies all the charges and her defense barrister, Ben Meyers, argues that the bleeding was the cause of death and questions the quality of care provided. He suggests that Baby E was a high-risk baby and had high blood sugar levels, which could have caused the bleeding.
Importance of Court Reporting and Open Justice
Professor Tim Crook, an expert in media law and former court reporter, highlights the importance of court reporting and the skills required to accurately and fairly cover trials. He emphasizes the significance of court reporters, noting that they often witness the manifestation of social and political issues in criminal cases. With the decline in specialist court reporters, Professor Crook commends the efforts of the podcast hosts in bringing details from the trial to the public and preserving the tradition of court reporting.
In this episode Caroline and Liz examine what happened to Baby E, a premature twin boy who Lucy Letby allegedly attacked with a plastic medical tube or wire before she murdered him. We hear from his mother, who the prosecution say, interrupted the nurse while she was attacking her son, and about more text messages Lucy Letby exchanged with colleagues after his death.
We also chat to former Old Bailey court reporter and media law expert Tim Crook, professor of journalism at London's Goldsmiths University, about why court reporting is still important in the modern era.