Hack It Out Golf The Greatest Player Ever
Nov 27, 2025
PGA Tour player Greg Chalmers joins Mark and Lou to tackle the age-old question of who is the greatest golfer ever. They dissect Gary Player's top choices and explore the difficulties of comparing players across different eras. Lou discusses how modern golf's accessibility and competition elevates the sport, while Chalmers offers insights on the barriers faced by past players. The trio debates criteria for ranking greatness, considers the legacy of iconic figures, and reflects on Tiger Woods’ profound impact on golf's global appeal.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Greatest-Of-All-Time Is Rule Dependent
- The question of the greatest golfer ever is fundamentally unanswerable without agreed rules.
- Mark Crossfield warns comparisons are emotive and often pointless on social media.
Modern Golf Gets Harder Over Time
- Lou Stagner argues sport becomes harder as knowledge and accessibility grow.
- He notes future players will be more talented due to broader coaching, fitness, and resources.
Set Clear Era Rules First
- Define clear rules or era windows before comparing players across time.
- Use era-specific comparisons to make the debate meaningful and fair.