Cooperation versus conflict and the path to multicellularity (Ep 107)
Oct 5, 2023
auto_awesome
Professors Joan Strassmann and David Queller from Washington University discuss the evolution of cooperation and conflict. They focus on their work with the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum, which helps understand the impact of relatedness on cooperation and the origins of multicellular organisms. They also touch on Joan's new book Slow Birding: The Art and Science of Enjoying the Birds in Your Own Backyard.
Understanding the evolution of cooperation involves concepts of kin selection and inclusive fitness.
Different levels of selection, such as kin selection and group selection, offer complementary perspectives on how selection operates.
Studying the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum can provide insights into the origins of multicellularity and the evolutionary pathways to complex life forms.
Deep dives
Kin selection and inclusive fitness
Kin selection and inclusive fitness are key concepts in understanding the evolution of cooperation. Kin selection refers to the selection for traits that benefit relatives, allowing altruistic behavior to increase within a population. Inclusive fitness takes into account the benefits of helping relatives in addition to individual fitness, which considers the number of offspring equivalents an individual produces rather than just the number of offspring.
Levels of selection
Selection is most potent at the level of the individual organism, as individuals are the primary agents in the world that have been shaped by natural selection. However, social insect colonies can also be considered individuals due to their long history of kin selection. The levels of selection, such as kin selection and group selection, are not necessarily competing explanations but rather different ways of understanding how selection operates.
Dictyostelium discoideum as a model organism
Dictyostelium discoideum is a social amoeba that forms multicellular slugs when food becomes scarce. These slugs then develop into fruiting bodies, with some cells sacrificing themselves to become the stalk supporting the others. The species demonstrates complex behaviors such as cooperation and cheating within a population. Despite being widely distributed, field studies are challenging due to the difficulty of observing microorganisms in their natural habitat.
Cooperation and conflict in complex organisms
Cooperation and agency are interconnected, as cooperation requires a unified goal. In understanding the evolution of complex organisms like humans, it is necessary to consider both cooperation and conflict resolution. While cooperation is central to the evolution of networks such as feed-forward loops and homeostasis, the key change in recent decades is the improved understanding of the mechanisms underlying these processes. This is attributed to advancements in genomic research, which have allowed scientists to delve into the intricate workings of genes and their activities. Another significant area of focus is conservation, as scientists strive to apply their knowledge of organisms to mitigate the ongoing extinction crisis.
Dictyostelium discoideum as a model organism for cooperation and conflict
Dictyostelium discoideum, commonly known as slime mold, exhibits a fascinating natural history that makes it an excellent model organism for studying cooperation and conflict. These amoebas come together and form multicellular structures called fruiting bodies when they encounter starvation. The self-regulating behavior of these organisms, which produce a stalk to benefit the survival of spores, raises questions about altruistic sacrifice. While Dictyostelium discoideum represents a specialized case of aggregating multicellularity, similar mechanisms can be found in other organisms. Exploring the natural history and behavior of organisms like Dictyostelium discoideum can shed light on the origins of multicellularity and the evolutionary pathways that could lead to the emergence of complex forms of life.
How can we reconcile the evolutionary problem of cooperation? What can social amoebae tell us about the origins of multicellularity?
In this episode, we talk to Joan Strassmann and David Queller, professors at Washington University in St. Louis, about the evolution of cooperation and conflict. From social insects to humans, we can find instances of individuals seemingly sacrificing fitness for the good of the group. But, truly altruistic behavior poses a problem for evolutionary biologists because it challenges the assumption that natural selection favors individuals over groups. We talk with Joan and David about their work with the social amoeba, Dictyostelium discoideum. This species is known for its remarkable developmental cycle: when there is no more to eat, the starving amoebae aggregate into a slug-like organism, which then forms a fruiting body that releases spores in hopes of dispersing to a better place. The problem, evolutionarily, is that only a fraction of the cells in the fruiting body get to live on through offspring. This facultative lifestyle and the ability to combine genetically different cells makes D. discoideum a prime study species for understanding how relatedness impacts cooperation and conflict and the possible origins of multicellular organisms.