Legal Expert Explains If Trump or the Courts Are Right | Josh Hammer
Mar 21, 2025
auto_awesome
Josh Hammer, Senior Editor at Newsweek and author of 'Israel and Civilization,' dives into pressing issues such as Trump’s immigration policies and the looming constitutional crisis. He explores the complexities of judicial overreach and emphasizes the vital role of Israel in defending Western civilization. Hammer discusses the rising threats to individual rights posed by ideologies like wokeism, while advocating for a unified moral vision against global anti-Semitism. His insights encourage an optimistic outlook for the future of the West.
The podcast discusses judicial overreach, emphasizing the urgent need for a Supreme Court ruling to address unconstitutional nationwide injunctions affecting governance.
It highlights the historical and civilizational ties between Jews and the West, positioning Israel's defense as vital for upholding shared values amid rising global threats.
The conversation identifies threats to Western civilization, including wokeism and global neoliberalism, urging strong leadership and a robust moral framework to combat these challenges.
Deep dives
The Power of Legal Interpretation
The discussion emphasizes the constitutional implications of judicial power, particularly regarding deportations and executive actions. It highlights a legal crisis, asserting that the courts have overstepped their boundaries by issuing nationwide injunctions that halt government programs. Historical references, including the Dred Scott case and Lincoln's noncompliance, illustrate that judicial rulings should only bind the parties involved in a case. The podcast argues for a Supreme Court ruling to clarify that broad injunctions are unconstitutional, which would ensure effective governance and prevent judicial overreach.
The Defense of Israel and the West
The conversation shifts to the defense of Israel, particularly in light of reactions to recent events, emphasizing the historical and civilizational connections between Jews and the West. It outlines the role of Jewish people in the foundation of Western civilization, with references to biblical texts and historical figures like Thomas Jefferson and William Bradford. The podcast posits that the existential threat to Israel parallels broader threats to Western nation-states, urging the necessity of supporting Israel as a defense of shared values and principles. This connection is underscored by the assertion that the fate of Jews often reflects the overall health of Western society.
The Threats to Western Civilization
Three main threats to Western civilization are identified: wokeism, Islamism, and global neoliberalism. Each of these forces poses unique challenges, with wokeism undermining traditional values through cultural Marxism, while Islamism represents a direct existential threat visible in recent terrorist attacks. Additionally, global neoliberal trends seek to erase distinctions that define societies, aiming for a homogenized global culture. The podcast warns that the rise of these ideologies indicates a civilizational battle that requires a robust moral framework to combat effectively.
Future of Western Societies
Concerns are raised about the potential disintegration of European nations amidst growing threats from within, with examples citing changes in demographics and cultural influences. The discussion speculates that without a coherent national identity and moral framework, some Western countries may lose their distinctiveness and sovereignty. This leads to a broader question about America's unique position in maintaining Western values, especially in the context of evolving political leadership. It suggests that if America can project strength and resolve, there is hope for a positive outcome in this civilizational struggle.
Optimism Amidst Challenges
Despite the overwhelming challenges facing the West, there remains a thread of optimism regarding the potential for recovery and resilience. The notion that ordinary Americans fundamentally possess goodness and a desire for truth underpins this optimism. The podcast asserts that strong leadership can mobilize citizens toward reaffirming shared values and promote happiness and meaning in life. It concludes that if the right conditions are fostered, with a return to foundational moral principles, there’s potential for revitalization and a more unified approach to facing persistent challenges.
Dave Rubin of “The Rubin Report” talks to Josh Hammer about his new book “Israel and Civilization: The Fate of The Jewish Nation and The Destiny of the West”; Trump’s immigration and deportation policies; if we are approaching a constitutional crisis; judicial overreach; the civilizational battle between Western values and rising global threats; Israel’s role as a key U.S. ally and defender of biblical principles; the need for strong leadership to preserve Western civilization amid internal and external challenges; an optimistic vision for the future of the West; and much more.
Check out the NEW RUBIN REPORT MERCH here:
https://daverubin.store/
----------
Today’s Sponsors:
Lumen.Me - Lumen is the world’s first handheld metabolic coach that measures your metabolism through your breath. It lets you know if you’re burning fat or carbs, and gives you tailored guidance to improve your nutrition, workouts, and sleep.
Go to: https://lumen.me/rubin to get 15% OFF!
Lean - A powerful weight loss supplement with remarkable results to help lower blood sugar, burn fat by converting it into energy, and curb your appetite.
Rubin Report viewers get 20% off plus free rush shipping off their first order!
Go to: https://TakeLean.com and enter promo code RUBIN20 for your discount
Rumble App - Looking for more freedom in your streaming? Download the Rumble app today and experience content like never before! Available on Android and iOS, you can take Rumble with you wherever you go, whether you're on the move or just relaxing at home.
