5 Days of Strategists - Episode 1254: The best laid pension plans
Nov 28, 2023
auto_awesome
Corey Hogan and Stephen Carter discuss Danielle Smith's play for an Alberta Pension Plan and Doug Ford's stunning Greenbelt reversal. Topics include the potential impact of the pension plan, investing in the oil sands industry, intentional defeat strategy, and analyzing the controversial Alberta Pension Plan. They also discuss the consequences of Doug Ford's action, risks and trust in pension funds.
The estimate that Alberta would receive under 20% of the CPP funds suggests that their claim for over half of the funds is unlikely to be accepted.
Doug Ford's decision to reverse the Greenbelt development in Ontario highlights his ability to rectify errors and differentiate his handling of the situation from other governments.
The lack of trust in the government's handling of funds and the potential negative impact on pensions make it improbable for Albertans to vote in favor of leaving the CPP.
Deep dives
The Alberta Pension Plan proposal is likely to receive less than 20% of the Canada Pension Plan funds
The proposal to withdraw from the Canada Pension Plan and create an Alberta Pension Plan is expected to receive under 20% of the CPP funds. This estimate is based on the understanding that Alberta's claim for more than half of the CPP funds is unlikely to be accepted. Given the asymmetry of information and the fact that Alberta's contributions do not necessarily directly translate to withdrawals in the province, the final amount allocated to Alberta is likely to be closer to its share of the population, around 16-17%.
Doug Ford's decision to reverse the Greenbelt development caused backlash but showcases his ability to rectify mistakes
Doug Ford's decision to reverse the Greenbelt development in Ontario, which initially caused public outrage, reflects his ability to rectify errors. Ford took decisive action to address public concerns and put a halt to the development plans, subsequently receiving criticism from within his caucus and leading to resignations. While there may still be further repercussions and legal challenges, the move demonstrates a politician's capacity to acknowledge and rectify mistakes, which differentiates Ford's handling of the situation from other governments.
Albertans are unlikely to vote in favor of leaving the Canada Pension Plan
It is unlikely that Albertans will vote in favor of leaving the Canada Pension Plan in a potential referendum. The initial low support for leaving the CPP, combined with arguments against the proposal, such as the lack of trust in the government's handling of the funds and the potential negative impact on pensions, make it improbable for the referendum to pass. Additionally, the benefits of remaining in the larger CPP system, including better returns and reduced risks through a larger pool of funds, make a compelling case for retaining the existing arrangement.
The importance of trust and the risks of active management for pension funds
Trust plays a vital role when considering proposals to change pension systems, such as the Alberta Pension Plan. The government's motivation for wanting to control the funds and the potential risks associated with active management raise concerns among Albertans. The example of the Quebec pension fund, which operates separately from the CPP and requires higher contribution rates, highlights the potential drawbacks of smaller, provincially managed funds. The size and stability of the CPP, along with its proven track record of effectively managing retirement funds, make it a more trusted and reliable option.
The ongoing engagement of progressives and the upcoming referendum on the Alberta Pension Plan
The engagement of progressives in the debate over the Alberta Pension Plan is significant, as they represent a growing force in countering the proposal. The potential low turnout for the referendum poses a challenge, but progressives are becoming more proactive in countering the arguments put forth by the government. Given the perceived lack of credibility in the claim that Alberta would receive more than half of the CPP funds, coupled with concerns about active management and the potential negative consequences for pensions, progressives are well-positioned to push back against the proposal.
It's the five days of Strategists! You, the non-paying listener get treated to five of our recent favourite paid episodes. See what you're missing and subscribe for as little as $6/month at: http://www.strategistspatreon.com
Tuesday - Episode 1254 - The best laid pension plans
Corey Hogan and Stephen Carter talk about Danielle Smith's play for an Alberta Pension Plan - and to take half the CPP with her on the way out the door - before turning to Doug Ford and a stunning Greenbelt reversal. Does Danielle Smith actually think she can get her hands on half the CPP, or is there something else going on? Has Doug Ford stopped digging down? And is Formula One the new AFL? zAIn Velji, as always, picks the questions and keeps everybody in line.