SAPIR Conversations S18E3: A Catholic Response to Jewish Chosenness with Professor Robert P. George
Oct 21, 2025
In a thought-provoking discussion, Robert P. George, a prominent Catholic legal scholar from Princeton, tackles the complexities of Jewish chosenness amidst rising antisemitism. He emphasizes that undermining the bond between God and the Jewish people contradicts Christian beliefs. George explores the implications of Pope Benedict's stance against supersessionism and reflects on the unique status of Judaism in Christianity. He also addresses the contemporary campus climate, advocating for open dialogue and free speech while confronting uncomfortable truths.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Anti-Semitism's Unwelcome Revival
- Robert P. George warns anti-Semitism is resurging among Catholics despite Vatican II's clear rejection of it.
- He says faithful Catholics cannot hold anti-Semitic beliefs or think God abandoned the Jewish people.
Benedict Rejected Replacement Theology
- George explains Pope Benedict opposed supersessionism and reasserted Judaism's ongoing covenantal status.
- He calls Marcionite replacement theology a long-condemned error the Church must reject today.
Judaism As Christianity’s Root
- The Second Vatican Council treats Judaism as uniquely foundational to Christianity and not merely another religion.
- George emphasizes Christians are grafted wild shoots onto the Jewish 'good olive tree' that is prior and central.
