Jason Johnson is joined by journalist David Betancourt to discuss the current state of comic book movies, the success of 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse', and the lack of representation in superhero movies, emphasizing the importance of diverse superhero films and the challenges they face.
The rise of streaming platforms and the convenience of watching movies at home have contributed to potential superhero fatigue and raised concerns about the sustainability of the genre.
The comic book genre has made significant strides in diversity and representation, but there is still a need to prioritize and explore more diverse characters in superhero movies.
Deep dives
Superhero and comic book movies dominate culture and box office
Superhero and comic book movies have become a dominant force in popular culture and have raked in massive profits at the box office since the 2000s. A string of successful films has turned actors into stars and legends. However, in 2023, the industry faced challenges with the rise of streaming platforms, leading to questions about the future of the genre. The convenience and accessibility of streaming movies have made some audiences less inclined to buy movie tickets and expensive popcorn. This has prompted discussions about potential superhero fatigue and raised concerns about the sustainability of the genre.
Recent underperformance and challenges for the comic book movie genre
The year 2023 was particularly challenging for comic book movies, with many major Marvel and DC films underperforming at the box office and some even being outright flops. Movies like The Flash, Marvels, and Aquaman did not meet expectations. Additionally, the firing of Jonathan Majors, who was supposed to play a pivotal role in the next three Avengers films, raised questions about the future of the comic book movie genre. These challenges have caused studios to reevaluate their strategies and consider alternative options, such as exploring other big villains like Doctor Doom.
The future of representation and diversity in comic book movies
The comic book genre has experienced a significant evolution in terms of diversity and representation in recent years. The creation of characters like Miles Morales, Nova, and Miss Marvel has showcased a more inclusive and authentic portrayal of superheroes. This shift has been fueled by a growing number of diverse creators, writers, and artists who bring their unique perspectives to the medium. However, there is still a need to further explore and prioritize diverse characters in superhero movies. This can pose challenges, as the success of these films often carries additional pressure and scrutiny. There is a desire to see more superhero movies headlined by people of color and LGBTQ+ characters, but there is also apprehension from studios due to potential backlash and online attacks from certain segments of the audience.
James Gunn's potential renaissance in superhero movies
With James Gunn now taking a leading role in the DC Universe of films, there is optimism for a potential renaissance in superhero movies. Gunn has proven his storytelling ability with the success of the Guardians of the Galaxy trilogy, where he crafted compelling stories around lesser-known characters. Now, with iconic characters like Superman under his direction, there is anticipation for fresh and innovative narratives. Gunn's experience and track record, coupled with the rich library of characters at his disposal, provide hope for the future of the DC film universe. While the Marvel Cinematic Universe may be transitioning to a new phase, Gunn's involvement could ignite new interest and excitement in the superhero genre.
Comic book films have dominated the box office for a generation, and gave many diverse actors and artists an opportunity to shine. But the genre struggled during 2023, and fans are worried that the golden age has ended for those movies and the culture that inspired them. On today’s episode of A Word, Jason Johnson is joined by journalist David Betancourt, who covered comic book movies and culture for The Washington Post for more than a decade. They talk about why superhero films may be going through a rough patch, and whether they can rebound.
Guest: Journalist David Betancourt, author of The Avengers Assembled: The Origin Story of Earth’s Mightiest Heroes
Podcast production by Kristie Taiwo-Makanjuola
You can skip all the ads in A Word by joining Slate Plus. Sign up now at slate.com/awordplus for $15 for your first three months.
