Helen Joyce, an Irish journalist and author known for her contentious views on gender identity, joins Dr. Jordan B. Peterson to discuss crucial issues surrounding women's rights and free speech. They tackle the challenges posed by censorship on platforms like YouTube and examine the implications of legislation on gender and hate speech. Joyce emphasizes the need for open dialogue about gender ideologies, especially regarding children's welfare. The conversation navigates the erosion of truth in public discourse and advocates for courage in voicing dissenting opinions.
The podcast emphasizes the importance of protecting freedom of speech and resisting censorship.
The conversation explores the potential consequences of criminalizing certain forms of speech, such as referring to biological sex or expressing differing views on gender identity.
The podcast raises questions about the definition of hate and the potential impact on free speech and privacy rights.
The conversation highlights the impact on women's safety and consent in situations where biological males are allowed access to previously gender-segregated spaces.
Deep dives
The importance of protecting freedom of speech
The podcast episode discusses the importance of protecting freedom of speech and resisting censorship. It highlights recent instances where conversations and podcasts have been taken down by platforms like YouTube, leading to concerns about the suppression of ideas and the impact on democratic discourse. The conversation also touches on the potential threat to natural rights and the consequences of silencing individuals who hold different viewpoints.
Challenges to free speech and the tyranny of false narratives
The podcast addresses the challenges faced by individuals who express their opinions openly and how certain ideologies are stifling free speech. It emphasizes the danger of allowing the creeping idea of hate speech to suppress straightforward factual statements. The conversation also explores the potential consequences of criminalizing certain forms of speech, such as referring to biological sex or expressing differing views on gender identity.
Concerns about legislation on hate speech and gender identity
The podcast delves into the discussion of legislation on hate speech and gender identity, particularly focusing on a proposed law in Ireland. It raises questions about the definition of hate and the potential impact on free speech and privacy rights. There is also a critique of the approach to gender identity and the potential medical consequences of early transitioning for minors.
The need to protect personal autonomy and safeguard single-sex spaces
The podcast explores the importance of protecting personal autonomy, privacy, and dignity, particularly in relation to single-sex spaces. It highlights the impact on women's safety and consent in situations where biological males are allowed access to previously gender-segregated spaces. The conversation emphasizes the need to provide spaces where individuals, particularly women, can feel safe and protected.
Standing up against bullies and defending free speech
The podcast episode features a discussion with Helen Joyce, a former journalist for The Economist, who faced backlash for speaking out about sex-based issues. She emphasizes the importance of standing up against bullies and defending free speech. Helen shares her experience of being supported by The Economist when facing criticism for her views, highlighting the backbone of the editor and the magazine's ethos of encouraging diverse opinions. She also discusses her current work with Sex Matters, an organization focused on advocating for sex-based rights, and her activities as a writer and writing tutor.
The consequences of breaking logical coherence
Helen Joyce and Jordan Peterson delve into the consequences of breaking logical coherence and allowing falsehoods in society. They highlight how accepting and promoting absurdities, like claiming men can be women, undermines the foundation of truth and meaningful discourse. This incoherence not only leads to confusion and anxiety among individuals, but also enables powerful ideologies to manipulate and control public narratives. They discuss how destabilizing basic truths and blurring distinct categories erodes the integrity of institutions and fuels moral confusion.
The significance of truth and the dangers of subjective supremacy
Helen Joyce and Jordan Peterson explore the significance of truth and the dangers of subjective supremacy. They emphasize the importance of truth in maintaining meaningful discussions and societal coherence. They highlight how certain ideologies, like queer theory, seek to undermine categories and destabilize coherence. They discuss the alarming consequences of allowing falsehoods to become accepted truths, which can lead to the degradation of language, confusion of identity, and the erosion of moral values.
The exploration of truth as adventure
Helen Joyce and Jordan Peterson discuss truth as an adventure and its alignment with the pursuit of beauty, clarity, and logical coherence. They explore the rewarding aspects of pursuing truth, even in difficult and chaotic times. They contrast the appeal of engaging in meaningful endeavors with the tedium of spreading falsehoods or engaging in meaningless activities. They highlight the courage and clarity of individuals who choose to pursue truth despite societal pressures and the potential consequences.
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson and Helen Joyce discuss the takedown of their last interview on youtube, the true tradition of women’s rights, and the harsh reality of what women stand to lose today.
Helen Joyce is an Irish novelist and journalist, acting as the executive editor for events and business at the Economist in London. Before this, she trained as a mathematician, graduating from the Trinity College in Dublin, before attending Cambridge. She then acquired a PhD in geometric measure theory at the University College London. She has held many roles as a journalist, working for PLUS Magazine and Significance Magazine, both of which have an emphasis on communicating complex math and statistics to the everyday reader. Later, she would spend three years as the Economist’s foreign correspondent to Brazil, living in São Paulo. In 2018, Joyce curated a series of articles on transgender identity, which led her to author the Sunday Times bestselling book, “Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality.”
- Links -
For Helen Joyce:
On Twitter @HJoyceGender https://twitter.com/HJoyceGender
Newsletter https://www.thehelenjoyce.com/
Help support Sex Matters https://sex-matters.org/
Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality (Book) https://www.amazon.com/Trans-When-Ideology-Meets-Reality/dp/0861540492
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
