Michael Knowles and guest John Yoo discuss how Hobbes's Leviathan shaped political philosophy. They explore Hobbes as the first modern political philosopher, his views on law, the relevance of his ideas in America, the symbolism of the monster Leviathan, and the conservative nature of the American Revolution.
Hobbes introduces the concept of the state of nature, describing life as 'nasty, poor, brutish, and short' without society or government.
Hobbes rejected the notion that the sovereign is appointed by God, instead championing the idea that society and government derive their legitimacy from the consent of the individuals.
Deep dives
Hobbes's Contribution to Modern Political Philosophy
In this podcast episode, the host and guest discuss the significance of Thomas Hobbes and his book 'Leviathan' in shaping modern political philosophy. They highlight three key points from Hobbes's work. First, Hobbes introduces the concept of the state of nature, describing life as 'nasty, poor, brutish, and short' without society or government. Second, he establishes the idea of the social contract, wherein individuals come together to form a government in order to maintain peace and order. Third, Hobbes introduces the concept of the sovereign, a separate entity from the people, responsible for governing the society. The guest emphasizes that Hobbes's views were often misunderstood, as he does not advocate for a specific type of government or imply absolutism. Rather, he focused on the government's role in preserving peace and order, allowing individuals the freedom to pursue their own lives within societal norms.
Hobbes's Departure from Medieval and Ancient Philosophies
The podcast delves into how Hobbes broke away from medieval and ancient philosophies. The guest explains that Hobbes rejected the notion that the sovereign is appointed by God, instead championing the idea that society and government derive their legitimacy from the consent of the individuals. Hobbes also diverged from the medieval emphasis on pursuing the highest good and aligning human law with God's law. He argued that the government's purpose is to prevent violence and maintain order, rather than dictate lifestyle choices or personal decisions that do not disrupt societal harmony. The guest further notes that Hobbes's approach to government as embodied in 'Leviathan' laid the groundwork for a more positivist understanding of law, where the focus is on written laws and the commands of the sovereign.
Hobbes's Influence and Contemporary Relevance
The episode concludes by discussing Hobbes's influence and his relevance in today's political landscape. The conversation highlights how Hobbes's ideas, such as the concept of a social contract and the need for a sovereign, formed the basis for modern political philosophy. Additionally, the guest draws connections between Hobbes's views and the principles of American constitutionalism, particularly the consent-based formation of government and the limited role of government in personal matters. The episode also touches on the ongoing debates surrounding liberalism and post-liberalism. While some question the foundations of liberalism, the podcast recognizes that Hobbes's ideas continue to shape political thought, highlighting the importance of understanding his work in order to grasp the historical origins of modern political systems.
Life is “nasty, brutish, and short.” That’s why we need a social contract—an exchange of freedom for security to avoid a dog-eat-dog state of nature. At least, that’s what Thomas Hobbes posited in Leviathan. Michael Knowles and guest John Yoo, Professor of Law at UC Berkeley, discuss how Hobbes’s seminal work has shaped political philosophy for centuries.